The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[xercesblue]

Is this fair?
and
this

both trades are very unfair for them... long tail shima is "common" rare ... isnt on any list... only have demand... both trades are big overpay for your dog

Agreed, both are huge overpay. I'm not sure, some people might be willing to pay more because of the horrific demand, but I don't really know.

Wrong.
1. Unfair to them rarity-wise, unfair to you greatly demand-wise. Shima's can go for a list pet.
2. Unfair to them rarity-wise, looks fair demand-wise, you should accept this.

[Lufi]

Wrong.
1. Unfair to them rarity-wise, unfair to you greatly demand-wise. Shima's can go for a list pet.
2. Unfair to them rarity-wise, looks fair demand-wise, you should accept this.

please... this is "fair trade thread" no "demand trade thread"
Both trade are very unfair for top offers... shima can go for list... but only crazy people do it... shima NOT WORTH list pet! and never will!

these two trades are together, so all of the one side for all of the other... do you think it's fair?
Here and Here
Would like another opinion on this one :3
~Flutter Shy

1st trade is really unfair to you...
2nd trade I'm little not sure but I think that its little unfair to you too (but here I'm really not sure)

both trades together = very unfair to you

[FOUND VERDICT]

Wrong.
1. Unfair to them rarity-wise, unfair to you greatly demand-wise. Shima's can go for a list pet.
2. Unfair to them rarity-wise, looks fair demand-wise, you should accept this.

please... this is "fair trade thread" no "demand trade thread"
Both trade are very unfair for top offers... shima can go for list... but only crazy people do it... shima NOT WORTH list pet! and never will!

I'm going to disagree here. demand is an important factor when trading and advice can/should be given on both rarity and demand.
And technically seen is an list pet not that much of an overpay, since bottom advents are worth 3 '09 rares.
Reasonable overpay for me

edit: just take some time and read the front page of the thread, DaDwarf explained it very well.

DaDwarf hat geschrieben:
This thread is about giving solid advice to people. Advice them on what would be good for their pets. what would be fair. Demand plays a huge role in that. Would you trade a BA for a dark leopard? probably not - you could get better. You know you could get better. Someone who doesn't know the demand, doesn't know they can get better comes here and gets the advice that a dark leo is fair without someone explaining that they can possible get more? They'll cut themselves in their fingers by accepting a trade that is 'fair' but not all they could've gotten.

Always give ALL advice.. Yes it's fair because - No it's unfair because. Or even - Without demand it would be fair, but you can get better - With demand it's probably fair but without it really unfair to them!

Either give all advice or nothing. That's what this thread is for, to help someone decide if a trade is fair to them, if it helps them.

[‍‍⠀]

Wrong.
1. Unfair to them rarity-wise, unfair to you greatly demand-wise. Shima's can go for a list pet.
2. Unfair to them rarity-wise, looks fair demand-wise, you should accept this.

please... this is "fair trade thread" no "demand trade thread"
Both trade are very unfair for top offers... shima can go for list... but only crazy people do it... shima NOT WORTH list pet! and never will!

I'm going to disagree here. demand is an important factor when trading and advice can/should be given on both rarity and demand.
And technically seen is an list pet not that much of an overpay, since bottom advents are worth 3 '09 rares.
Reasonable overpay for me

Agreed . a shima can go for as high as a 3 tier advent. this thread also include demand not only rarities and date. so technically it's an overpay.

[Vraska the Unseen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4om01R5hmA

My side is the PBD, I'm not quite sure about the Rudolph rat for it though.

[Lufi]

I'm going to disagree here. demand is an important factor when trading and advice can/should be given on both rarity and demand.
And technically seen is an list pet not that much of an overpay, since bottom advents are worth 3 '09 rares.
Reasonable overpay for me

edit: just take some time and read the front page of the thread, DaDwarf explained it very well.

DaDwarf hat geschrieben:
This thread is about giving solid advice to people. Advice them on what would be good for their pets. what would be fair. Demand plays a huge role in that. Would you trade a BA for a dark leopard? probably not - you could get better. You know you could get better. Someone who doesn't know the demand, doesn't know they can get better comes here and gets the advice that a dark leo is fair without someone explaining that they can possible get more? They'll cut themselves in their fingers by accepting a trade that is 'fair' but not all they could've gotten.

Always give ALL advice.. Yes it's fair because - No it's unfair because. Or even - Without demand it would be fair, but you can get better - With demand it's probably fair but without it really unfair to them!

Either give all advice or nothing. That's what this thread is for, to help someone decide if a trade is fair to them, if it helps them.

okay... I dont read front page very long ^^ so this is "new" for me
tnx for info

[FOUND VERDICT]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41521173&userid=224548&signature=nqc0tsRj7oGg4om01R5hmA

My side is the PBD, I'm not quite sure about the Rudolph rat for it though.

They'd need to add an Lime Ice Rat (or something of it's value) and an low advent to make it fair

[Vraska the Unseen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41521173&userid=224548&signature=nqc0tsRj7oGg4om01R5hmA

My side is the PBD, I'm not quite sure about the Rudolph rat for it though.

They'd need to add an Lime Ice Rat (or something of it's value) and an low advent to make it fair

Thank you. ^.^ I've also had someone offer two punk dogs for it, kind of scared me.

[FOUND VERDICT]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=41521173&userid=224548&signature=nqc0tsRj7oGg4om01R5hmA

My side is the PBD, I'm not quite sure about the Rudolph rat for it though.

They'd need to add an Lime Ice Rat (or something of it's value) and an low advent to make it fair

Thank you. ^.^ I've also had someone offer two punk dogs for it, kind of scared me.

That's definitely a bit less, he should be worth 6-7 mid advents ^^

[leafless willow]

Which Is The Fairest For My Target Dog?

~1: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d1V1a_CtDg

~2: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xb-jhnwJmw

~3: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NXzayF8dMw

~4: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... c_Iah9VAvg

Ty For Your Help/ Guidance c: