Plumerian Fanclub ♥ V.2 - New Thread!

[Master of Nothing]

I probably won't be participating if the tiers are decided based off of the quality of the art. It's just... rude really. :T

Fair point... well, let's say this: the higher tiers could be based off of effort, not quality. Anyone?

[Hiroko]

[Blackhusky]

I probably won't be participating if the tiers are decided based off of the quality of the art. It's just... rude really. :T

Fair point... well, let's say this: the higher tiers could be based off of effort, not quality. Anyone?

yeah that is what I was thinking, because then some one with descent art that is too ashamed to call it hq would be stuck with people who one give like 2 pieces and they give like 10 .. ;//v//;

[monty]

I probably won't be participating if the tiers are decided based off of the quality of the art. It's just... rude really. :T

Fair point... well, let's say this: the higher tiers could be based off of effort, not quality. Anyone?

^ That sounds a lot better. There's people who put a lot of time and effort into art but it still doesn't look the best/what they want it to look like.
The thing with deciding high quality/low quality art/medium quality, someone can get hurt. You have to draw the line somewhere and looking at someone's art and saying "eh, it's medium quality" just doesn't seem like a nice thing to do.

[Rabbit]

It would be neat to have a little side contest, too, to kinda motivate people, instead of a tier? It can be done with tiers too

but like

judges judge based on quality, quantity, and effort? Maybe other things too idk

[Charchar2]

Oh yeah, tiers would be based solely off effort/how much you want to be involved! Like person A might want to just doodle a thing or two, so they'd be in a more "casual" tier, while person B might want to draw a whole lot and order lots and just make a huge bundle for their person, so they'd be in a more ""intense"" tier. It wouldn't be like person A has "good" art so they're in a different tier than person B who has "bad" art, since art's "goodness" is really just in the interpretation and anyways that's awfully rude xD;

and oooo that sounds neat xerberus *v*

[wingz.]

I probably won't be participating if the tiers are decided based off of the quality of the art. It's just... rude really. :T

personally I think that if the tiers are based on level its more fair as you are getting a product equal to your own. Its like a basic bartering system. Don't get me wrong, mixing artists is fine, only when someone puts hours of effort into their pieces and it looks incredible and they are paired with a base artist who spent a half hour at the most its not exactly fair. This is a problem I have run into in the past and dont wish to repeat. If the sides aren't even I wont be participating :/

[agathokakologic]

Yea, I personally think that if someone works really hard and gets placed in the bottom tier, while an amazing artist does quick sketch that's placed in the top tier, they would probably feel a lot less confident about their drawing skills.

[monty]

Oh yeah, tiers would be based solely off effort/how much you want to be involved! Like person A might want to just doodle a thing or two, so they'd be in a more "casual" tier, while person B might want to draw a whole lot and order lots and just make a huge bundle for their person, so they'd be in a more ""intense"" tier. It wouldn't be like person A has "good" art so they're in a different tier than person B who has "bad" art, since art's "goodness" is really just in the interpretation and anyways that's awfully rude xD;

and oooo that sounds neat xerberus *v*

bless you char

-

Random questions i pulled off of lord knows where. Not really feeling it to answer them myself but eh.

Code: Select all

[b]What are your plumerians proudest of?[/b]
[b]Greatest accomplishment?[/b]
[b]What is their first memory with their best friend?[/b]
[b]How do you want them to be remembered?[/b]
[b]What do you think they'll be like in 10 years?[/b]

-

edit, adding in,
Yes, I understand not wanting to be paired with someone who gives you small doodles and whatever, but tiers open a window for the whole event to turn elitist real fast. With the amount of drama that could happen, it's easier to just go with what Char said.

[Rabbit]

There should also be something to fall back on, too, so if there's artists that are willing to do additional art for those that didn't get their gift or not a fair one, that would be nice too.

Maybe the amount of art for backup artists could try to be equal to how much the person gave?