The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[♔-Jᴜɴᴋᴏ Eɴᴏsʜɪᴍᴀ-♔]

Oh ok, thank you

[radiantly]

I've added every cat I'm willing to trade, but I know it's still unfair to them.

What pet(s) or item(s) on their side should be removed to make it fair?
They want the cats for an auction, so there's 64 cats added onto my side.

Hi everyone. I am re quoting this for Hyrule. I am the trading partner in the second trade and would also please like to know what I need to remove or add to make it fair? Thank you so much!

[lucky333123]

I'm not super comfortable with evaluating pet-for-item trades. Opinions?
Thank you in advance.

I'm not going to evaluate this one for obvious reasons, but to let everyone know the items are from the summer '12 event.

[NocturnalPanda]

Would a Pocky be fair for the July Lioness? Thank you!

[kapetrovaa]

Would a Pocky be fair for the July Lioness? Thank you!

Unfair to Pocky.

[~Mia~]

Would a Pocky be fair for the July Lioness? Thank you!

Unfair to Pocky.

Agreed.

[NocturnalPanda]

Would a Pocky be fair for the July Lioness? Thank you!

Unfair to Pocky.

Agreed.

Thank you both! How much more would need to be added to the Lioness' side?

[The Smiler]

I recently received this - I think it's unfair but I can never be certain. They themselves cancelled it after a while of me ignoring it, but I want to know in case I ever recieve an offer similar to it again.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8MU9K4c8mg

[BraveEguana]

Hi!
Could somebody tell me how you would "call it" in numbers? 1-10?
So... Which bid is better?
Number 1
Number 2

[Queen~of~Crows]

I recently received this - I think it's unfair but I can never be certain. They themselves cancelled it after a while of me ignoring it, but I want to know in case I ever recieve an offer similar to it again.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8MU9K4c8mg

Very unfair to you.