The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[MiniBookworm]

Fair?
If not, what needs to be changed?

[Erwin Smith]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39531242&userid=636560&signature=yoJH8EI9fzDE1dw3lMdkNA
fair ?

Unfair to the Red Rose's Side.
The Demand of the Raven Dog has died down a little due to there not being many out actively for trade or auction, And in any case, the Raven Dog will not be the worth of a Red Rose for a very long time, if it ever does.
If you want to get a trade based solely on the demand of the Raven Dog, that is pretty much only be able to be accomplished by you and your partner, we can't say or control demand at all, and thus we offer advice and reply based on the worth.

What would have to be added to their side? We both know it's unfair but we're not sure on what should be added.

From what I have read, the Eat me cake is 3CS in the shop and I believe what you have on the other side of the trade, not the BMD, is worth about Grinner, maybe a few uncommons off depending on the worth of the items, which I couldn't find on the Item Worth threads. (I'm guessing the St Pat's hat is worth a 10 Uncommon Max since it is not with the rest of the set and the Nick Cake is a '10 uncommon)
The difference between a Grinner and a BMD is approximately a Grey Border Collie, or 7 or so 09 rares.

[marina.]

red rose+blue rose=BA?

[Takk]

red rose+blue rose=BA?

Unfair to the roses as the tier gap is a little less than a grinner, demand wise the BA can for more so people often expect more

[inkyst]

Is this fair?

[forevermine]

Is a true red rose equal to an august pps lion?

[Ashki]

Is a true red rose equal to an august pps lion?

Extremely unfair to the red rose.

[April410]

I'm not good with the rares list. Fair for her or me, and if not, how can I fix it so both parties are happy?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39531009&userid=30963&signature=rutsHb2QJRTB2QUvfzceQw

thank you to whomever trys to help me!

[Flaming]

Demandwise, is a Red Rose or BMD worth more?

[Ashki]

Demandwise, is a Red Rose or BMD worth more?

They have around the same demand. It depends on who you trade with.