The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Sweetfrog]

Is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Pi2O-L5vYg

[Sayuri-Hime]

Is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Pi2O-L5vYg

unfair to you, tha gap between balloon and butterbun is more than a few advents

[Sweetfrog]

Is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Pi2O-L5vYg

unfair to you, tha gap between balloon and butterbun is more than a few advents

What is the gap?

[Sayuri-Hime]

Is this fair ?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Pi2O-L5vYg

unfair to you, tha gap between balloon and butterbun is more than a few advents

What is the gap?

each gap (between two tiers) on the mainlist is about an low septemberlist from what I was told.
and the bun is 5 or 6 gaps above the balloon. so around an rose pps is needed to fill that gap.

not sure what exactly they need to add to the advents though

[Demonking Urizen]

Is this bid fair to the White Feb demandwise? Thank you
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ak8zdM_b4w

[|| B r o k e n ||]

Is this an alright trade? Thanks in advance

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fkVudivU9A

[Jackdaw Lord]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=39188603&userid=393277&signature=5xjQvApp87Ts_-srEa5kig
Warning. Large trade. Their 77 pets for my Dark Leopard?

DL worth ~ 40 2009 Rares

12-18 pets - 2008 green butterfly wolf, 2009 ladybug bw, 2009 spider, 2010 dog

Opinion 1 - Unfair to DL

Can I get an opinion with what can be added to make it fair?

1 2008 (2008 green butterfly wolf)
15 2009 rares + 1 + 1 (2009 ladybug bw, 2009 spider) = 17
2 2009 uncommon
14 2010 rares
30 2010 uncommon + 1 (2010 dog)
5 2011 rares
2 2011 uncommon

Even if we value 2 uncommons = 1 rare (which is a pretty eh method, as far as I'm concerned), it'd still work out something like this:

Base 17 2009 rares.
2008 rare = 2 2009 rares
2 2009 uncommons = 1 rare
14 2010 rares = 7 2009 rares
30 2010 uncommons = 15 2010 rares = 7.5 2009 rares
5 2011 rares = 2.5 2010 rares = 1.something 2009 rare (this is ridiculous, I admit)
2 2011 uncommons = ????? (I don't think they even weight much if anything at all for this trade)

Either way, all added up we'd get something like 17 + 2 + 7.5 + 7 + 1 = 35 or whereabouts

Which is not 40. But it's difficult to figure out how much the pets are worth, especially in such a quantity and with such different tades (imo it'd be very hard to trade those 15 2010 rares for 7 2009 rares, so it's kinda a moot point in those conversions).

Demand wise, it seems to fare even worse. The trade has a bunch of low demand pets (rats, spiders, etc.) and only a handful of dogs.

I stay by what I said earlier and say it's unfair, both with or without demand. As for what should be added? If you don't care about demand, then at least another 5 2009 rares.

But anyone, feel free to contradict me.

[diana,]

Is this a far trade? Thank you for any answer!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I2K6dthNUA

[Demonking Urizen]

Is this a far trade? Thank you for any answer!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I2K6dthNUA

Unfair to them, a 2014 rare is worth a 2012 uncommon.

Is this an alright trade? Thanks in advance

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... fkVudivU9A

Unfair to the Grinner by 2 '09 rares

[Silverstar]

Is this a far trade? Thank you for any answer! :D
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... I2K6dthNUA

Unfair to them.