September 2014 Discussion Thread

[astar]

I think I might have a theory on who's this is.

Jadeghost said their hint was "Red and blue, three and two."

Because red and blue make purple, this one seems obvious.
But Jade did say that their dog might have three tails as a pup, and two as an adult or visa versa.

Yes, I know my theories aren't all that exciting. But my guess is that this 3-tailed pup is Jadeghost's.

...Am I the only one thinking "red and blue" probably means the adult dog will have red/blue heterochromic eyes?

I mean..."purple" is kind of a lame hint when that's one of the major colors of the palette.

I was thinking that too, but then I saw the eyes were a blue-green. So it wouldn't really work.

And if you just use the hint as its purple, it'll be even more difficult to know which is who's.

[ROCK*STAR]

where's the "hint board"?

[Hush]

where's the "hint board"?

In the outcomes thread

[Pyromaniacal]

I have a theory that may or may not actually be valid, but according to Vampiric's clue "As these eyes close, others open" makes me think of this dog...

[ROCK*STAR]

I have a theory that may or may not actually be valid, but according to Vampiric's clue "As these eyes close, others open" makes me think of this dog...

gah, i was ninja'd! i was just about to post the same exact thing ;o;
i think so, too. but there still might be another dog whom's eyes are closed..

[DragonGirl218]

I think I might have a theory on who's this is.

Jadeghost said their hint was "Red and blue, three and two."

Because red and blue make purple, this one seems obvious.
But Jade did say that their dog might have three tails as a pup, and two as an adult or visa versa.

Yes, I know my theories aren't all that exciting. But my guess is that this 3-tailed pup is Jadeghost's.

...Am I the only one thinking "red and blue" probably means the adult dog will have red/blue heterochromic eyes?

I mean..."purple" is kind of a lame hint when that's one of the major colors of the palette.

I was thinking that too, but then I saw the eyes were a blue-green. So it wouldn't really work.

And if you just use the hint as its purple, it'll be even more difficult to know which is who's.

Then...it's not a hint for this dog? Seems easier to wait and match a hint to an appropriate dog than to try to twist a hint until it fits your predefined notion of which dog it should belong to. Who knows, maybe a later pup will have a red eye facing us with three spines and two wing-nubs on its back or something.

[Pika Girl]

What page is it that Metallic Dragon claimed their pup?

[Pyromaniacal]

I have a theory that may or may not actually be valid, but according to Vampiric's clue "As these eyes close, others open" makes me think of this dog...

gah, i was ninja'd! i was just about to post the same exact thing ;o;
i think so, too. but there still might be another dog whom's eyes are closed..

That's true, especially since this lil guy doesn't seem much like Vampiric's other staff dogs.

But you never know...

[flyteck]

I have a theory that may or may not actually be valid, but according to Vampiric's clue "As these eyes close, others open" makes me think of this dog...

gah, i was ninja'd! i was just about to post the same exact thing ;o;
i think so, too. but there still might be another dog whom's eyes are closed..

That's true, especially since this lil guy doesn't seem much like Vampiric's other staff dogs.

But you never know...

I think this one is Dracas. I have no clue what her hints were, but it just seems to match her style.

[ParaKitty]

I think this one is Dracas. I have no clue what her hints were, but it just seems to match her style.

She said, "As these eyes are closed, others open."