The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[astar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=37188490&userid=568416&signature=x2haDL9T8U8k9dZV93ynuQ
Is this fair?
Thanks!

I believe it is unfair to them. Your pets are from 2014 and that lion is from 2012. This is year wise. The items still dont make it fair.
Correct me if i am wrong.

very unfair to the bottom
The very rare dogs are store pets and worth mid-late 09 rares

I'm actually going to have to disagree with you Trouble. Your forgetting about demand on the July Lioness, I honestly think the store pets won't even be enough to cover the demand. I've seen July Lioness' go for much more than 2 store pets, some items, and an uncommon dear.
So it is actually very unfair to the July Lioness.

Edit: ehh. I accidentally put my wording in Trouble's quote. Oops! I just fixed it so problem solved ^^;

[Eternal Flame]

Is This A Fair Trade? Sorry For Reposting But I Never Got a Answer
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IhCneEXkEw

[YourGayness]

This fair? What could be added and to which side? Considering demand, lists and overall worth?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4Q5fwTIvow

Thanks in advance! ^^

It's unfair to you, add a High September to their side. ^_^

Thanks for the advice ^^ would you happen to know if a ur Apple, a Grinner, a very rare warrior cat and a Malk smiley is a fair trade for the wood angel considering demand?

[DuckGoesRawr]

I'm actually going to have to disagree with you Trouble. Your forgetting about demand on the July Lioness, I honestly think the store pets won't even be enough to cover the demand. I've seen July Lioness' go for much more than 2 store pets, some items, and an uncommon dear.
So it is actually very unfair to the July Lioness.

Edit: ehh. I accidentally put my wording in Trouble's quote. Oops! I just fixed it so problem solved ^^;

Trouble is right, rarity wise its unfair to the bottom. It's not your decision to decide the lioness's demand, it's up to the traders.

[astar]

I'm actually going to have to disagree with you Trouble. Your forgetting about demand on the July Lioness, I honestly think the store pets won't even be enough to cover the demand. I've seen July Lioness' go for much more than 2 store pets, some items, and an uncommon dear.
So it is actually very unfair to the July Lioness.

Edit: ehh. I accidentally put my wording in Trouble's quote. Oops! I just fixed it so problem solved ^^;

Trouble is right, rarity wise its unfair to the bottom. It's not your decision to decide the lioness's demand, it's up to the traders.

I know It's not my decision on the demand, but the july lioness does have have a lot of demand. There's no hiding that, but I also have seen the July lioness go for much more than the trade sent. If it were me with the July lioness, I would remember it has demand and won't take couple 2014 store pets and items for it.
I'm aware the trade is unfair to the store pets rarity wise, but I trade with demand more and I just think it's unfair to the July lioness.

[Costelle]

Could i get answers? Had them for about 3 pages now...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L-a-pRzugw
and
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FlN4kP3uww

Second opinions are welcome

First one is very unfair to them.

[Takk]

Could i get answers? Had them for about 3 pages now...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L-a-pRzugw
and
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FlN4kP3uww

Second opinions are welcome

First one is very unfair to them.

Both are unfair to the other person. 2 '09 rares are plenty for the rat and the border collie is worth 8 '09 rares I think

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

I'm actually going to have to disagree with you Trouble. Your forgetting about demand on the July Lioness, I honestly think the store pets won't even be enough to cover the demand. I've seen July Lioness' go for much more than 2 store pets, some items, and an uncommon dear.
So it is actually very unfair to the July Lioness.

Edit: ehh. I accidentally put my wording in Trouble's quote. Oops! I just fixed it so problem solved ^^;

Trouble is right, rarity wise its unfair to the bottom. It's not your decision to decide the lioness's demand, it's up to the traders.

I know It's not my decision on the demand, but the july lioness does have have a lot of demand. There's no hiding that, but I also have seen the July lioness go for much more than the trade sent. If it were me with the July lioness, I would remember it has demand and won't take couple 2014 store pets and items for it.
I'm aware the trade is unfair to the store pets rarity wise, but I trade with demand more and I just think it's unfair to the July lioness.

i respect demand but it doesn't change the fairness of a trade, which I was basing things off of ^^
Only what the pet goes for. The lioness can go for more, but that's not necessarily a bad offer

Could i get answers? Had them for about 3 pages now...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L-a-pRzugw
and
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FlN4kP3uww

Second opinions are welcome

First one is very unfair to them.

Both are unfair to the other person. 2 '09 rares are plenty for the rat and the border collie is worth 8 '09 rares I think

agreed
Though the border collie is worth seven 09 rares

[YourGayness]

would anyone happen to know if a ur Apple, a Grinner, a very rare warrior cat and a Malk smiley is a fair trade for the wood angel considering demand? I know demand for the apple is horrible

[DuckGoesRawr]

Could i get answers? Had them for about 3 pages now...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L-a-pRzugw
and
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FlN4kP3uww

Second opinions are welcome

First one is very unfair to them.

Both are unfair to the other person. 2 '09 rares are plenty for the rat and the border collie is worth 8 '09 rares I think

7th tiers are worth 7 mixed '09 rares, I believe the bottom trade is around fair because the pink rat is a '08 very rare re-release

would anyone happen to know if a ur Apple, a Grinner, a very rare warrior cat and a Malk smiley is a fair trade for the wood angel considering demand? I know demand for the apple is horrible

Unfair to the wood wing c: