The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

My gallery · by **Mckarca** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:02 pm

Is this fair to them?

My gallery · by **BlingBling** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:02 pm

Mckarca wrote:Is this fair to them?

Quite unfair to them ^^

My gallery · by **TheCalicoTabby** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:04 pm

Could I please get some advice on this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6QH1syu4ug

I've been getting a lot of offers for my warrior cats, though I cancelled most because they were offering much newer pets. A 2008 dog, on the other hand, is tempting. I'd just like a second opinion before I accept, since I'm not great at valuing older pets.

My gallery · by **Dragonborn Comes** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:05 pm

TheCalicoTabby wrote:Could I please get some advice on this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6QH1syu4ug

I've been getting a lot of offers for my warrior cats, though I cancelled most because they were offering much newer pets. A 2008 dog, on the other hand, is tempting. I'd just like a second opinion before I accept, since I'm not great at valuing older pets.

It would be unfair to them by rarity, but the demand of the warriors can get you much more then the dog.

My gallery · by **astar** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:07 pm

TheCalicoTabby wrote:Could I please get some advice on this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6QH1syu4ug

I've been getting a lot of offers for my warrior cats, though I cancelled most because they were offering much newer pets. A 2008 dog, on the other hand, is tempting. I'd just like a second opinion before I accept, since I'm not great at valuing older pets.

Well, if you take off any 2 of the pets on your side that they asked for it would be a fair swap, rarity wise. Unless one or both of your warriors are re-releases. Then, I wouldn't have a clue.

My gallery · by **Fat Unicorn** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:07 pm

TheCalicoTabby wrote:Could I please get some advice on this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6QH1syu4ug

I've been getting a lot of offers for my warrior cats, though I cancelled most because they were offering much newer pets. A 2008 dog, on the other hand, is tempting. I'd just like a second opinion before I accept, since I'm not great at valuing older pets.

Those October Striped Dogs are usually worth 2 early 09 rares, so I'd say that was slightly unfair to them technically. The Malk Wolves would've amounted to a earlyish/middish 09 Rare together easily, and the Warrior Cats are worth a mid 09 rare each (and together they'd be worth a early 09 rare pretty easily). c:

My gallery · by **bears** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:08 pm

Is this overpay on their part?

My gallery · by **Fat Unicorn** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:14 pm

Mother Of Bears wrote:
Is this overpay on their part?

No, it's unfair to you. ^^

My gallery · by **bears** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:18 pm

Fat Unicorn wrote:
Mother Of Bears wrote:
Is this overpay on their part?

No, it's unfair to you. ^^

She's offering overpay, and has added more pets. Should I ask for more, or leave it as is?

My gallery · by **TheCalicoTabby** » Wed Jul 16, 2014 2:22 pm

*~Star-Dust~* wrote:
TheCalicoTabby wrote:Could I please get some advice on this trade?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6QH1syu4ug

I've been getting a lot of offers for my warrior cats, though I cancelled most because they were offering much newer pets. A 2008 dog, on the other hand, is tempting. I'd just like a second opinion before I accept, since I'm not great at valuing older pets.

It would be unfair to them by rarity, but the demand of the warriors can get you much more then the dog.

my-insanity wrote:Well, if you take off any 2 of the pets on your side that they asked for it would be a fair swap, rarity wise. Unless one or both of your warriors are re-releases. Then, I wouldn't have a clue.

Fat Unicorn wrote:
Those October Striped Dogs are usually worth 2 early 09 rares, so I'd say that was slightly unfair to them technically. The Malk Wolves would've amounted to a earlyish/middish 09 Rare together easily, and the Warrior Cats are worth a mid 09 rare each (and together they'd be worth a early 09 rare pretty easily). c:

Alright, thanks for the advice!

The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Re: The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

Who is online