The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[FOUND VERDICT]

If I removed all the items would this be fair? I know the pocky alone is worth more than the dog...

trade

Thank you in advance!

The pocky is only worth an 09 rare.
The Grey Mini Husky is three tiers under the White Santa Cat, so they'd need to add two 09 rares + one 09 uncommon (plus you should remove all items on your side)

[musicgurl333]

If I removed all the items would this be fair? I know the pocky alone is worth more than the dog...

trade

Thank you in advance!

The pocky is only worth an 09 rare.
The Grey Mini Husky is three tiers under the White Santa Cat, so they'd need to add two 09 rares + one 09 uncommon (plus you should remove all items on your side)

I believe Pocky is actually worth a '08 rare from October or November according to the item guide. Other than that, I agree.

[FOUND VERDICT]

If I removed all the items would this be fair? I know the pocky alone is worth more than the dog...

trade

Thank you in advance!

The pocky is only worth an 09 rare.
The Grey Mini Husky is three tiers under the White Santa Cat, so they'd need to add two 09 rares + one 09 uncommon (plus you should remove all items on your side)

I believe Pocky is actually worth a '08 rare from October or November according to the item guide. Other than that, I agree.

really? I found that in the "How much is this Item Worth" Thread.

Halo and Pocky
Halos are worth a rare from September '08. Pocky are only worth an early 09 rare.

[Fruity Girl]

Is this fair ?
Thanks ! ~

[foresti]

would this be fair? thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1hyk0OPxCw

[FOUND VERDICT]

would this be fair? thank you!
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 1hyk0OPxCw

It depends on how much you'd value the PPS Lion. Some people do pay a rare for them, so if you include demand leave one of the rares and 2-3 chickens (since you don't know their rarity yet, and they could get common or very common) on your side

[elder price]

If I removed all the items would this be fair? I know the pocky alone is worth more than the dog...

trade

Thank you in advance!

The pocky is only worth an 09 rare.
The Grey Mini Husky is three tiers under the White Santa Cat, so they'd need to add two 09 rares + one 09 uncommon (plus you should remove all items on your side)

I believe Pocky is actually worth a '08 rare from October or November according to the item guide. Other than that, I agree.

i second that pockey is worth a late '08 rare/very rare
taken from the items guide draft on pg 86:

Oct/Nov 08 Rare/Very Rare
...Pocky - Christmas 2008

also, not sure if you guys noticed, but there are three pockeys involved in that trade.
i'd say it would be fair if you remove everything except the pockeys and added one or two '09 uncommons to your side, Inari Rose. c:

[rockandroll666]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mbg8Dnotlw

Is this fair? if not what needs to be added?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

If I removed all the items would this be fair? I know the pocky alone is worth more than the dog...

trade

Thank you in advance!

The pocky is only worth an 09 rare.
The Grey Mini Husky is three tiers under the White Santa Cat, so they'd need to add two 09 rares + one 09 uncommon (plus you should remove all items on your side)

I believe Pocky is actually worth a '08 rare from October or November according to the item guide. Other than that, I agree.

i second that pockey is worth a late '08 rare/very rare
taken from the items guide draft on pg 86:

Oct/Nov 08 Rare/Very Rare
...Pocky - Christmas 2008

also, not sure if you guys noticed, but there are three pockeys involved in that trade.
i'd say it would be fair if you remove everything except the pockeys and added one or two '09 uncommons to your side, Inari Rose. c:

the cat alone is overpay for the husky, marsh ^^
The top needs to add 2-3 09 rares [no items included]

[Baylin]

What could be added to their side then?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Kk3uLQopQg
Thank you!