Ask for help with character/plot development or other RP-related content. You can also post your own roleplay guides, tips, and tricks!
by troyards » Sun Jun 29, 2014 7:27 am
can i ask for clarification on what qualifies for "fan-use?" it's kinda vague and doesn't sit right with me.
i'm gonna be talking most in terms of tumblr since that's where most of the gifs come from but this may be applicable other sites.
tumblr's tos only extends sharing through reblogs (listed under item 6) unless the creator explicitly states (works kinda like how icon comms on livejournal work wherein the creator either says sourcing isn't needed or just to source to the post) that it's for public use and a lot of the gif edits aren't for public use. so if i were to use a gif from a gifset of annie leonhardt from attack on titan (or any character from any show, really. reason why i'm using annie is bc anime source material is really easy to find if you know where to look and it's what i had), according to tumblr's tos, i cannot, but according to here i can since the source is technically there and i would have to link to that and it's a gif so under the subsection as it is right now, it's for fan-use. however, here's where my issue comes in: i technically can't use those gifs since they aren't meant for fan-use. i'm assuming that if i make my own gifs for use here i can use them since they're kinda derivative works and they should work the same way photomanipulations work on deviantart.
(image of the source attribution i'm talking about. it's listed as origin (kinda wish i could link to the actual post but w/e w/e i think this gets my point across))
also gifs rarely have watermarks (if there's a watermark it's kinda faint) so you have to go by what the source attribution says if the caption isn't formatted so that one part of it links to the op but even that's iffy.
tumblr is listed as one of the places to not get reference images from since it's impossible to source, but i don't think people know that? honestly, i've never seen an image on this board sourced correctly (the most i've seen is copyright to respective/rightful owners and that ain't sourcing. it's akin to saying weheartit/zerochan/"i'm not sure!" on tumblr) and i know i should report them but it's just so many that i'd rather not flood the mods (kinda lazy on my part and makes the problem worse but there's just SO MUCH of it). sourcing isn't even that hard since you can do some bbcode trickery to hide the url line so idk why things aren't sourced properly. (i've also found stuff hosted on imgur and i'm not sure if they're personal edits or reuploads to avoid getting "no more bandwidth" banners so idk)
the only place where i can see it feasible to get pictures for celebrity face claims is from a fan gallery (like this one here) and they're pretty easy to find if you just google "(celeb name) gallery" if they're a well known celebrity. fashion models would also work (i had a gallery for that but i lost it and i wish i could find it again) and it may be harder for lesser known celebrities/youtubers but a little digging never hurt anybody and if they aren't willing dig, they probably weren't going to source correctly in the first place. kinda can't do this with anime unless you either have the source material or find a screencap repository/official art dump but source material is kinda easy to find nowadays and art book scans are always a thing
idk maybe i'm talking in circles but that subsection never really did sit right with me with the whole "most gifs are distributed for fan use!" thing when most of them aren't even if they get lost in the constant reuploading/reposting spiral. not under cc so....
tl;dr: gifs/gif edits/edits in general kinda aren't for fan-use bc of tumblr's tos and they aren't under cc licensing. should maybe stick to celeb galleries for celeb faceclaims but jury's kinda out on anime faceclaims if you can't find the source material to make gifs or any official art/a screencap repository.
if i kinda didn't explain things right just shoot me a pm or s/t and i'll try my best to clarify (might be rambly and not make sense so bear with me since i can't link to specific posts on my tumblr.)

pfp, no. 68//quote from wolf 359 s1e11, "am i alone now?"
-

troyards
-
- Posts: 1715
- Joined: Mon Sep 22, 2008 3:02 pm
- My pets
- My items
- My wishlist
- My gallery
- My scenes
- My dressups
- Trade with me
-
by Lacuna » Sun Jun 29, 2014 5:43 pm
AcetheKidd wrote:Umm..that was..abit confuseing
Anyway, this site seem really legit. If they where stealing art, i think they would had shut it down. I researched the the site and it they explains stuff.
http://www.renders-graphics.com/
I'm not sure what you're saying they explain, as the site has no rules about their content that I can see (the rules board in their forum has no topics). I did however find several instances in the forum where artists were complaining that their art had been used to create renders without their permission, so I would not use this site.
┌───────────────┐
│
│
│
│
│
│└───────────────┘
-

Lacuna
-
- Posts: 11907
- Joined: Sat Apr 09, 2011 6:50 pm
- My pets
- My items
- My wishlist
- My gallery
- My scenes
- My dressups
- Trade with me
-
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 0 guests