The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[Arrows]

What about this? I really need to know. I'm not sure what's up with the advents and all, but is this fair? Thank you!

[Cake.]

Fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sf6ekOWPJg

So, using the C$ worth guide, here is what I got:

Blue Rose: 260-280
P B-wolf: 65
2009-10: 25-30
2010-10: 15
2010x6: 90 (because store pets are value at '10 rare)

The range for these ten pets is 455-480, and is isn't even count the rereleased horses. So it's unfair to the pet side. ^^

That's not how C$ works. You add up the pets' value and then convert the highest possible pet you could get into C$

For example, two Candy Cane Horses don't equal a red dragon.

The trade is unfair to the C$, because 450 C$ is enough to get a Light Speckled Rat.

★ But they're not asking for the highest possible value. They're asking for the worth of eah pet. That's why I told them and then totaled it. If they wanted to know the highest possible list pet for their C$, they would've asked that.

[AmnesiaUndead]

? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... avgw98LzNQ

Very unfair to you.

second?

[Lady Sif]

So, using the C$ worth guide, here is what I got:

Blue Rose: 260-280
P B-wolf: 65
2009-10: 25-30
2010-10: 15
2010x6: 90 (because store pets are value at '10 rare)

The range for these ten pets is 455-480, and is isn't even count the rereleased horses. So it's unfair to the pet side. ^^

That's not how C$ works. You add up the pets' value and then convert the highest possible pet you could get into C$

For example, two Candy Cane Horses don't equal a red dragon.

The trade is unfair to the C$, because 450 C$ is enough to get a Light Speckled Rat.

★ But they're not asking for the highest possible value. They're asking for the worth of eah pet. That's why I told them and then totaled it. If they wanted to know the highest possible list pet for their C$, they would've asked that.

The way you find the C$ value of a group of pets, is you total the pets' value and then convert that value into C$.

Look at it this way:
Blue Rose = 7 Mid-advents
Mid-advent = 75 C$
7 * 75 = 525 C$

But wait, a blue rose is only worth 260-280 C$ according to the guide.

Pet values and C$ values work differently, because C$ is bought with real money. That's the way it has to work in order to be reasonable.

If we didn't do it that way, a UR tiger/sunjewel would be worth almost 5,000 USD. Way more than anyone would ever pay.

Don't believe me? Take a look:

Staring from mid-advent tier:
Blue Rose = 7 Mid-advents
Balloon Dog = 3 Blue Roses
Yellow Toxic = 2 Balloon Dogs
Sorbet = 2 Yellow Toxics
Non-dog = 3 Sorbets
UR Tiger = 5 Nons

75*7*3*2*2*3*5 = 94,500 C$/19 (The lowest price you can get C$ for)=
4,973.68....

Which would be a ridiculous amount to spend on pixels.


That's why you can't add up C$ prices, you have to add up pet prices and then convert.

Also, they weren't asking for the C$ values of all the pets. They were asking if the trade was fair.

[.:Haru:.]

My partner has a great knowledge of rarities, but I'm super indecisive with big trades like this, so can I get a secondary opinion before I make a decision?
Click!
Preferably someone who's good with items/C$/list pets.
Also, does anyone know if the Non has good demand typically?

Thanks!

[Lady Sif]

My partner has a great knowledge of rarities, but I'm super indecisive with big trades like this, so can I get a secondary opinion before I make a decision?
Click!
Preferably someone who's good with items/C$/list pets.
Also, does anyone know if the Non has good demand typically?

Thanks!

Honestly, I think it's unfair to you. I'm seeing a lot of older items that are worth a fair bit + a Rainbow mane in C$.

I wouldn't take it. A lot of the items on your side are pretty hard to find.

[AmnesiaUndead]

? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... avgw98LzNQ

Very unfair to you.

second?

[Lady Sif]

? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... avgw98LzNQ

Unfair to you. The pets on their side are worth 230 C$ at best.

Also, A note to everyone:
Only post your trade ONCE PER PAGE. Do not wait 1-3 posts and then post your trade again. I will repeat that. ONCE PER PAGE.

[Delete*]

Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VLpTI4g5Kg

[Besketball]

Fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VLpTI4g5Kg

Unfair to them, since new store pets are worth a mid-2010 rare. c: