The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[To The Roses]

This person and I have been sending trades back and forth. We can't seem to settle on an agreement, but is this a fair offer anyways? Just checking to see if it's me that's being unfair.

[To The Roses]

Hi!
Is this trade fair?

*click*

not fair to you, but i would get a second opinion

[Shawn.pineapple]

Hi!
Is this trade fair?

*click*

not fair

[20lait1]

Is this trade fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GhHY_xk6og

[Shawn.pineapple]

This person and I have been sending trades back and forth. We can't seem to settle on an agreement, but is this a fair offer anyways? Just checking to see if it's me that's being unfair.

unfair to u

[мσƨƨғıяε]

Hi!
Is this trade fair?

*click*

not fair to you, but i would get a second opinion

not fair

@Charcoal.Night: is it for me or for they unfair?
And thanks for your answers (:

[DaDwarf]

Please STOP Double posting! it's SPAM and not allowed anywhere on CS.
We've got an edit button for a reason.

I'm going to repost this notice as people seem to not under the 'please no uneducated advice' type of rule we have here.

Please read

The FTT helps you determine if a trade is worth taking. When giving advice, please give all the advice you have. Don't just post 'fair'/ 'unfair'. Post a whole sentence! 'No, that's unfair to you BECAUSE ...' or 'Yes, that's fair but it might be hard to trade...' and so on and so on.

This thread is about giving solid advice to people. Advice them on what would be good for their pets. what would be fair. Demand plays a huge role in that. Would you trade a BA for a dark leopard? probably not - you could get better. You know you could get better. Someone who doesn't know the demand, doesn't know they can get better comes here and gets the advice that a dark leo is fair without someone explaining that they can possible get more? They'll cut themselves in their fingers by accepting a trade that is 'fair' but not all they could've gotten.

Always give ALL advice.. Yes it's fair because - No it's unfair because. Or even - Without demand it would be fair, but you can get better - With demand it's probably fair but without it really unfair to them!

Either give all advice or nothing. That's what this thread is for, to help someone decide if a trade is fair to them, if it helps them.

PLEASE NOTE, POSTING 'FAIR/UNFAIR' HARDLY HELPS ANYONE. PLEASE GIVE EDUCATED ADVICE AND ELABORATE/EXPLAIN WHY!!

[Shawn.pineapple]

is this fair

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z3AOYC9-PQ

[Shawn.pineapple]

Please STOP Double posting! it's SPAM and not allowed anywhere on CS.
We've got an edit button for a reason.

I'm going to repost this notice as people seem to not under the 'please no uneducated advice' type of rule we have here.

Please read

The FTT helps you determine if a trade is worth taking. When giving advice, please give all the advice you have. Don't just post 'fair'/ 'unfair'. Post a whole sentence! 'No, that's unfair to you BECAUSE ...' or 'Yes, that's fair but it might be hard to trade...' and so on and so on.

This thread is about giving solid advice to people. Advice them on what would be good for their pets. what would be fair. Demand plays a huge role in that. Would you trade a BA for a dark leopard? probably not - you could get better. You know you could get better. Someone who doesn't know the demand, doesn't know they can get better comes here and gets the advice that a dark leo is fair without someone explaining that they can possible get more? They'll cut themselves in their fingers by accepting a trade that is 'fair' but not all they could've gotten.

Always give ALL advice.. Yes it's fair because - No it's unfair because. Or even - Without demand it would be fair, but you can get better - With demand it's probably fair but without it really unfair to them!

Either give all advice or nothing. That's what this thread is for, to help someone decide if a trade is fair to them, if it helps them.

PLEASE NOTE, POSTING 'FAIR/UNFAIR' HARDLY HELPS ANYONE. PLEASE GIVE EDUCATED ADVICE AND ELABORATE/EXPLAIN WHY!!

but how will we now who we are talking to

[Shawn.pineapple]

is this fair

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z3AOYC9-PQ

is this fair