The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[PeachFuzz]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... htWbO9_OMw
I'm curious, would this be fair?
i'm not going to accept cause I love that pet, but just for future reference.

[OceanBlast]

I know this is unfair to me, but what do they need to add?

Actually I'd say that's unfair to them because I don't believe the two September lists add up to the Mainlist Dark Pnk Shima-B Wolf but please correct me if I'm wrong ^^

[HappyPineapple]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35967289&userid=334063&signature=yqj9nnyEqz6UhtWbO9_OMw
I'm curious, would this be fair?
i'm not going to accept cause I love that pet, but just for future reference.

Unfair to the bottom. The gap between rare and very rare is too large to be covered by 3 rares.

[Kex.]

I know this is unfair to me, but what do they need to add?

Actually I'd say that's unfair to them because I don't believe the two September lists add up to the Mainlist Dark Pnk Shima-B Wolf but please correct me if I'm wrong ^^

Agreed, it also seems to me that the trade is unfair to the top.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

I know this is unfair to me, but what do they need to add?

Actually I'd say that's unfair to them because I don't believe the two September lists add up to the Mainlist Dark Pnk Shima-B Wolf but please correct me if I'm wrong ^^

Agreed, it also seems to me that the trade is unfair to the top.

please don't give false advice
This is unfair to the bottom by about 2-3 mid ascents or about a target-scarf pps

[Sagaline]

Would this be fair?

Any help appreciated (:

Unfair to you

Thank you (:
Would it be fair if I remove one of the dogs on my side?

[мσƨƨғıяε]

~trade~

Hi! Would anyone help me with this trade?
For me it looks fair, but I wanted to first obtain me a few more opinions.

[Silverstar]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tyA73ABqbw

[The Cab]

i heard grinners have bad demand but I'm not sure all the pets on my side are advents

[[Shadow]]

They sent this trade to me and I am extremely uncertain of the fairness for me.

Is this fair for me? I don't think so...