The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[lucky333123]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=35593635&userid=5911&signature=MnHG2Bwt7Q6EqfrUy9TXsw

i am lost o.o

Unfair to the top

[katarinabluu]

IS THIS FAIR ???

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 609vkd7JVg

[lucky333123]

IS THIS FAIR ???

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 609vkd7JVg

Please don't use all caps. It is unfair to the top

[RegaliaDown]

IS THIS FAIR ???

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 609vkd7JVg

I'd say probably a bit unfair to you, since it's a '09 Tes cat, but, then again, the store pets are really beautiful. It's a very nice offer, but I personally wouldn't accept. I'm not 100% sure; you'd have to get a more experienced member's opinion.

[Alerian]

I want expert traders only! I don't want 2014 users who don't know anything about the rares list.

I think this is unfair but can I get an opinion? What could they add?

[invadersparkscat]

Do you guys think this is fair?

Thanks in advance! ^^

[.muse.]

IS THIS FAIR ???

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 609vkd7JVg

I'd say probably a bit unfair to you, since it's a '09 Tes cat, but, then again, the store pets are really beautiful. It's a very nice offer, but I personally wouldn't accept. I'm not 100% sure; you'd have to get a more experienced member's opinion.

These kinds of trades are always iffy.
Because accordingly a new store pet is worth about a 2010 rare, but the set of store pets was originally bought for 60C$. 60C$ could get you an advent list pet, whereas that cat cannot.
So if you go by the store pets being worth a 2010 rare, it's unfair to the cat. If you go by the store pets C$ values, it's unfair to the store pets.
This is something that will always be screwed up in the trade economy here on CS, and it's really up to you which you want to trade by.
I always trade store pets by their C$ value, but that's just me.

I want expert traders only! I don't want 2014 users who don't know anything about the rares list.

I think this is unfair but can I get an opinion? What could they add?

That is wildly unfair to the Malk UR. Their side totals up to about a Balloon dog, which is only half the worth of the UR Malk.

[Patch.]

I want expert traders only! I don't want 2014 users who don't know anything about the rares list.

I think this is unfair but can I get an opinion? What could they add?

There's no need to be like that. 2014 users can learn the List and 2009 users can be clueless.

Unfair to the UR Malk.

[Alerian]

Apologizes for acting like that Patch. I just am always getting pms and from them and they give me false advice. I have another trade I need advice on

i think this is unfair but I need an opinion

[.muse.]

Apologizes for acting like that Patch. I just am always getting pms and from them and they give me false advice. I have another trade I need advice on

i think this is unfair but I need an opinion

I'd say that's also unfair to the UR Malk. By the list placement, those advents all added together don't even equal a blue rose.