The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Tesalong]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34647215&userid=397484&signature=Fkvbyr8P-7CLezQRonLzHw
Is this trade fair to both us and if not, what needs to be added?
Thanks in advance!

Unfair to them, I believe.
Not sure what needs to be added, though.

[Foxen]

I can't decide wich bid to make the winning bid.
I have made out my 4 favorite bids
But I can't decide wich one should be wise to accept later

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ThS8EgjziQ
this one has:
- line tribal
- target <3
- heart advent
- Brown border collie
- white feb <3
- hollyfoxcat
- pale blue spotted advent 2x
- malk smiley
- red cerberus <3
- gearback
- Timber dog
- GWJ
- July lioness <3
- July PPS <3
- cream advent
- blue PPS malk dragon <3
- pink cake dog
- blue ice swirl
- spotted tribal bun
- flower toxic rat
- some rares+uncommon+very rares

2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RnpNW6zmRA
This one has:
- Dogtag
- UR Bee <3
- Gearback
- 2 sorbets
- 100 C$

3. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 2CSxMWsJtA
This one has:
- spotted tribal
- coontail
- Pink balloon
- GWJ
- Dark grey tag husky
- Desert/orange swirl PPS
- Green toxic
- Non Jewel <3
- UR Holly wing
- 500 C$

4. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BYFkK4wXKw
This one has:
- Joker <3
- Green malk dragon
- Sunjewel <3
- smiley
- 500 C$

I really like the first bid with the quantity and the awesome pets in it.
But I love the jokerdog. Is it possible get a joker with the first bid?
I also like the second bid, but I don't know how the demand is of those pets.
The third one looks awesome too
And the 4 is (I think) The most overpay. The sunjewel stands on the same tier as the tigerdog I especially love the Joker but I think I can get him to with the first bid.
I love the first bid the most at the moment but would it be wise to accept that one or should I do one of the others?

I'm sorry that this is so much text
Thanks in advance!

~leetje

To be honest, I'd say all of them except the last bid is unfair to you. The fairest of all is the 4th bid, it's the best however a overpay to their side witch is unfair to them, by everything except the sun jewel. (:

[Akele]

Would these three dogs:


Be worth this?


If this trade isn't fair, what needs to change?

[Foxen]

Would these three dogs:


Be worth this?


If this trade isn't fair, what needs to change?

No, sorry ):

[세레비]

I don't have any specific trade yet, but i'm just here to ask: A GBC (Gray Border Collie) is fair to trade for a Hollyfox Dog or a Vixen Dog Advent? Thanks!

[Foxen]

I don't have any specific trade yet, but i'm just here to ask: A GBC (Gray Border Collie) is fair to trade for a Hollyfox Dog or a Vixen Dog Advent? Thanks!

A Vixen dog advent is the best (:

[niv]

I don't have any specific trade yet, but i'm just here to ask: A GBC (Gray Border Collie) is fair to trade for a Hollyfox Dog or a Vixen Dog Advent? Thanks!

Yes, It would be fair tier swap c:

[세레비]

I don't have any specific trade yet, but i'm just here to ask: A GBC (Gray Border Collie) is fair to trade for a Hollyfox Dog or a Vixen Dog Advent? Thanks!

Yes, It would be fair tier swap c:

I don't have any specific trade yet, but i'm just here to ask: A GBC (Gray Border Collie) is fair to trade for a Hollyfox Dog or a Vixen Dog Advent? Thanks!

A Vixen dog advent is the best (:

Oh okay, thanks for answering. <3

[Demonking Urizen]

Is here somebody who's a bit good in quatity trades?
I put up my 586 pet-hoard for auction, the auto is a 7th tier advent.
Is this a totally idiotic dream or just quite fair?

[Zoella]

We've been editing this back and forth for a while. I just feel that it's a bit unfair to me because the target dog is a list pet...but I'm no good with quantity, so any help is very much appreciated. <3

A Target is worth ~ 13 - 15 early-mid '09 rares.
So it's unfair to them, but please get a second opinion.

Ok thanks! c: Another opinion please?