The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Zyra]

Okay, on my Shima Longtail I was offered
I've researched the demand for the Shima for a bit, and from what i have gathered the Shima is worth a mid-September to high-september list. And that's what the palamino is, a mid-september.
Keep in mind that the Shima isn't even on the list, its just the demand that sky rockets it, Like what happened with the August PPS. (Which i think SHOULD be only worth a mid-high advent.) So i suggest making the trade if the shima isn't way too valuable to you. You can trade it up to some good pets like the Malk White Dragon :3. I suggest getting a second opinion though. I'm not a professional

I agree as far as considering demand goes. Lists are lists, but it's supply and demand that decide value... which is why I'm wondering that, although on a "list", is the Palamino desired by people at all? That is to say, as a "trade" goes, am I losing trading capability by getting the horse, or gaining some?

[Druid~]

Fair?

[leetje]

Wich one is the best?? Thanks for any help!!
for 78 lions (V-day+this month)
♥ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cp7w9gizbA
for 15 this month lions:
♥ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... q3l5ZrqRvw
♥ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ErsjapWa2Q
for 63 V-day lions:
♥ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LG1241Od2Q
for the 9 V-day PPS lions:
♥ http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hD2iux-WMg

[legitamoose]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... YDJjBb5mFQ
Is this unfair? Please help.

[Borealisphoenix]

I would like to Know how fair this is its a bid for my auction and i really like http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dHQadTXE0Q

I'll just tell you what some of them are worth, as where the Phoenix is in the rarities area hasn't been clearly stated yet.

The Pink Balloon Dog is a Low Rares List.
The Grey Mini Husky is a Low Advent List.
The Celestial PPS is a High Advent List.
The Black Advent is worth a High September List
The three dogs next to the brown and red pps are unknown to me, but have Decent Demand
So is that Brown and Red PPS, Low Demand
The PPS aussie pups have slightly high demand, but aren't on any list as far as i know.
The Blood PPS is worth a High September List
Shimas are normally worth a mid-high September list if the person who is getting it thinks its a high price, But at its lowest its normally worth a Low-Mid Advent
The Blue Balloon Dog is the same tier Rares List as the Pink one.
The Grinner is a low September List
The Brown Dog with a Purple Collar have decent demand, but i don't know if they are on a list or not.
The Heart PPS is a High Advent List, But be cautious, They are smaller than other pps so it will be hard to dress it up :c
The Boar PPS is same tier as the Heart PPS in the Advent List
And the last dog...err i don't know. I haven't seen anyone ask for that before either.

I Personally think this batch would be worth possibly Two Toxics? Maybe? If you consider the Phoenix being below the Big Gap in the Rares list, it would probably Fair, maybe the teeniest Overpay on your side. But please get a second opinion, This is only what i think the batch of pets would be worth.

[Borealisphoenix]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=34465407&userid=355028&signature=Oc_Ida-HNg26O-N6sbrnmw

Hi! Fair?

Ty<3

Unfair to you, The Store Pet would probably cover the Plasma Scythe, and maybe the 2010 Malk Wolf, maybe. But their only pet older than 2013 in the trade is the Dragon, which is only a uncommon.

[King M'skay]

I would like to Know how fair this is its a bid for my auction and i really like http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dHQadTXE0Q

I'll just tell you what some of them are worth, as where the Phoenix is in the rarities area hasn't been clearly stated yet.

The Pink Balloon Dog is a Low Rares List.
The Grey Mini Husky is a Low Advent List.
The Celestial PPS is a High Advent List.
The Black Advent is worth a High September List
The three dogs next to the brown and red pps are unknown to me, but have Decent Demand
So is that Brown and Red PPS, Low Demand
The PPS aussie pups have slightly high demand, but aren't on any list as far as i know.
The Blood PPS is worth a High September List
Shimas are normally worth a mid-high September list if the person who is getting it thinks its a high price, But at its lowest its normally worth a Low-Mid Advent
The Blue Balloon Dog is the same tier Rares List as the Pink one.
The Grinner is a low September List
The Brown Dog with a Purple Collar have decent demand, but i don't know if they are on a list or not.
The Heart PPS is a High Advent List, But be cautious, They are smaller than other pps so it will be hard to dress it up :c
The Boar PPS is same tier as the Heart PPS in the Advent List
And the last dog...err i don't know. I haven't seen anyone ask for that before either.

I Personally think this batch would be worth possibly Two Toxics? Maybe? If you consider the Phoenix being below the Big Gap in the Rares list, it would probably Fair, maybe the teeniest Overpay on your side. But please get a second opinion, This is only what i think the batch of pets would be worth.

Ok thanks for your help

[Borealisphoenix]

I just got another offer for the Black Advent, i can't choose D: I need help knowing which one is fairer...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9_bPe_cRoQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GPjli7iyig

[Zoella]

Can someone help me with this trade? I know rarity wise it isn't even, but what about demand?

[Demonking Urizen]

Can someone help me with this trade? I know rarity wise it isn't even, but what about demand?

The Drink me & Eat me have decent demand, but the demand of the Tess horses is horrible.
Still unfair to you, even with the bad demand of the Tess horses.