The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Faela]

And is this fair? They cancelled literally right away
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... byyTtTbh8g

Um, sorry, it was unfair to them. A 2011 Target Dog doesn't amount to a bunch of 2009 and one 2008 very rare cats. Sorry!

Don't give false advice, the Target Dog is a September List pet and is worth much more than any one of those. That being, I think it was unfair to you, but not hugely, probably by about 4-5 09 rares?

[SquishyZebra]

[quote="Sonmi-451"][quote="fabled rose x"][quote="_smeller_"][quote="Icyfrost"]What wools they need to add?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BeAt4YnN6Q
Target dog is only September list, so I disagree. I'd say about 3 more rares.

[Penguingps]

And is this fair? They cancelled literally right away
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... byyTtTbh8g

Um, sorry, it was unfair to them. A 2011 Target Dog doesn't amount to a bunch of 2009 and one 2008 very rare cats. Sorry!

Don't give false advice, the Target Dog is a September List pet and is worth much more than any one of those. That being, I think it was unfair to you, but not hugely, probably by about 4-5 09 rares?

Oh, my gosh. How did I miss that?! Sorry for the false advice! My brain is soo weird today.

[SquishyZebra]

Which bid is better?
Bid 1
Bid 2
Thanks in advance. c:

First one

[daices.]

Fair?

[britneyrox]

i know this is unfair to them, so what value of C$ would be fair?

[britneyrox]

Which bid is better?
Bid 1
Bid 2
Thanks in advance. c:

number 1! c:

[lainey_lane03]

Is this a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mTv3hvkQUA

Second thoughts please ^.^ Thank you for the info! The rat is a low tier advent and on their WL so I wasn't sure...I figured it was likely over but wasn't sure so any other info would be much appreciated! I don't want to take advantage of them but I don't want to short change myself either

[catsmaycry]

Is this a fair trade?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... mTv3hvkQUA

in my opinion this trade is unfair to them because the rat that you're offering is quite low in demand and rats by itself is low in demand. and I am not sure what the ate of the rat is.. and also because the store corgi IS going to be a Very Rare I think it is unfair on there part but its just my opinion I want second thoughts if im wrong

Second thoughts please ^.^ Thank you for the info! The rat is a low tier advent and on their WL so I wasn't sure...I figured it was likely over but wasn't sure so any other info would be much appreciated! I don't want to take advantage of them but I don't want to short change myself either

I would say unfair-is to the rat. Even if they have low demand, this one is still on the advent list as you have said. Get another opinion on this, but if I remember correctly, they are worth aroun 3-4 09' rares (a mid advent is worth 7).

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33655540&userid=516957&signature=41tsBqaYctHXlSU25KXi1Q Fair-ish? If not, what should each side add?

Hard to tell, but for what I have seen on the auction forums, it is unfair to the UR phoenix.


My question is: what should be added to a BA and a BMD to make it fair to a joker?

[Shep.]

• How fair is this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xTZVTpsH0w
~ Shep ;;