The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Unseen~Before]

I am pretty sure this is overpay, but then, I haven't traded for awhile so I'm not sure;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hye0XcAW-w

I am 88% sure it is not fair, but again, I haven't traded in forever.

Overpay for the otherside. Their rat is from Feb 2009

[MyNiallBear]

I am pretty sure this is overpay, but then, I haven't traded for awhile so I'm not sure;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hye0XcAW-w

I am 88% sure it is not fair, but again, I haven't traded in forever.

I think its unfair for them but then again the smile is popular

[KupferudelWolf]

I just got another bid. Is this fair? Once again, thank you in advance. ^^

Unfair to the Peppermint Eared Advent.

Dark Shima B Wolf = August pps lion

Obviously OVERPAY(I'm pretty sure). However, does the B wolf have much demand?

The August PPS Lion is only worth a 2012 Very Rare, but you may get more with its demand. The Dark Shima B-wolf is a List pet, worth much, much more.

I completely misread your question, sorry. Er...from my experience, its demand is adequate.

[beemo]

Dark Shima B Wolf = August pps lion

Obviously OVERPAY(I'm pretty sure). However, does the B wolf have much demand?

Yes, it's obviously heavy overpay.
It hardly has any demand though.
In this case though, the demand of the Shima doesn't even matter because it's so high on the list, and the August PPS is not a list pet, nor will it ever be.
I feel badly for the person offering that, they must be very desperate, but you should take that offer, it's probably the best you'll get.

[Miyazaki]

I am pretty sure this is overpay, but then, I haven't traded for awhile so I'm not sure;
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hye0XcAW-w

I am 88% sure it is not fair, but again, I haven't traded in forever.

It's definitely unfair to them, but you should note that rats are very hard to trade off, even very rare ones. The corgi definitely has demand, though.

[Unseen~Before]

Dark Shima B Wolf = August pps lion

Obviously OVERPAY(I'm pretty sure). However, does the B wolf have much demand?

Yes, it's obviously heavy overpay.
It hardly has any demand though.
In this case though, the demand of the Shima doesn't even matter because it's so high on the list, and the August PPS is not a list pet, nor will it ever be.
I feel badly for the person offering that, they must be very desperate, but you should take that offer, it's probably the best you'll get.

Thank you for the response I feel bad as well, but they said they hope I get something good from it since it's ovepay. . . so I guess they are sure? Anyway, thanks!

[the family business]

I'm not sure if this is fair or not?

[MyNiallBear]

I'm not sure if this is fair or not?

ok I guess it is unfair to the apple, but the VR cat is 2009 alreadly

[KupferudelWolf]

I'm not sure if this is fair or not?

Very unfair to the UR Apple.

[beemo]

I'm not sure if this is fair or not?

personally I think your overpaying but the apple is worth it

That's incorrect, it's very unfair to the Apple.