The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Penguingps]

Help anyone? I really want it to be at least a little fair to both of us. Any replies are greatly appreciated!

I haven't trades tess horses since before they went very rare; however when they were rare they were worth a mid '09 rare.
I would assume they're now worth a mid '09 very rare; and so going by this, it looks roughly fair, perhaps *slightly* unfair to you.
however it would probably be best to get a second opinion, as I'm not 100% sure c:

Thanks! Second opinion? (Fourth time posting..)

[Tack]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... rW9XTT3C6A

Is this fair?

Any help is appreciated, thank you.

Very unfair to you, your warriors are worth at least 25 C$ each and the uncommon warrior cats are worth at least more than 5 C$ each.

Okay, so maybe about 70 C$, then?

[bnom]

@Xxtoboexx;;
The first one is still best.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33572992&userid=29623&signature=scM8p-hweP3lSyF-4NSjbQ
fair?
these re-release trades are starting to annoy me. ._.

Unfair to them;; The snow leopard dog is from 2010 while there's is from 2009.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33572736&userid=287959&signature=To11Pjafndo75i8mlN8Xag

I highly doubt I'm overpaying but rather safe than sorry

Looks unfair to them, considering it is a UR, though not on the list yet.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33565452&userid=292734&signature=Ke9j8Kpw_nnIrDMAqHgJ2g

They offered; I don't want to offer more, but I feel like they're possibly overoffering since store pets are rares.

Considering the Store pets will probably be VR, unfair to them.

[limalicious]

Thanks, Ferncat. I knew they were overoffering, but not that badly.

I neither want to guilt of ripping them off, nor do I want to feel the necessity to offer more, so I may just reject all around. =/

[Patch.]

Help anyone? I really want it to be at least a little fair to both of us. Any replies are greatly appreciated! :thumbup:

I haven't trades tess horses since before they went very rare; however when they were rare they were worth a mid '09 rare.
I would assume they're now worth a mid '09 very rare; and so going by this, it looks roughly fair, perhaps *slightly* unfair to you.
however it would probably be best to get a second opinion, as I'm not 100% sure c:

Thanks! Second opinion? (Fourth time posting..)

I agree with the opinion given. And...if nobody knows if you're trade is fair or unfair, be patient. I think you'd prefer eventual good advice instead of quick bad advice. ;3

[dorksoup]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5OSunBdn4Q

Since the last one was apparently completely unfair is this one any better
FYI all the pets in offering are on their wishlist

[Patch.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33573304&userid=287959&signature=0xkAGeQlYQzW5OSunBdn4Q

Since the last one was apparently completely unfair is this one any better
FYI all the pets in offering are on their wishlist

That's up to you and your partner to decide. The new URs don't have a range, so as long as at least a Main List pet is being offered, you're on the right track. :3

[Pirate Spawn]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33556963&userid=384553&signature=J7puk-7I3Aam-AS7tfw6Rg

Being that it is an April 2010 Malk Wolf, what could I add to make it fair?

[waste of prince]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ZWEmCs-J2A
Fair? ^^

[Patch.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=33573355&userid=464624&signature=qo1C0m806-VrZWEmCs-J2A
Fair? ^^

Unfair to you. Both those second gens were available for several months, so they're offering a mid/late 2009 uncommon and 2010 uncommon.