add-on list, regarding nov/oct 08's, discussion thread.

[rose;]

are all of the october spots/stripes being added? It doesn't seem like that's all of them, or maybe that's just me and I'm thinking wrong nevermind, looking in the wrong places. although I do have to ask why they're on different tiers?

I do have to agree that the camo dog probably can be moved up, for demand, mostly. I've had a heck of a time trying to get one, just one. There's a lot of people who will hoard them for honoring military family and such

And the orange BW is generally valued higher than the spiderwing, in my experience. I found them less while I was searching [bw collector here]. I remember conversing with another collector and they said the same- we both had a harder time trying to find it than the BW on the low advent list. I would assume more were just in locked groups, as the design seems generally more liked than the spiderwing for some reason

[DerbyGirl]

I third the camo dog being moved up. I'd rather see it with the card dogs-it's got very good demand, and it is a pain to find. And usually people value it the same as the card dogs-or higher.

Edit: while I am thinking of it...early '11 store horses. Those things are a pain to find and go for a good chunk, from what I hear. With all due honesty, they can't be all that more common than the store pets that are at the bottom of the Advents List...and I know those are all up for debate on moving up, so might be time to consider those for this?

[fidelity]

Edit: while I am thinking of it...early '11 store horses. Those things are a pain to find and go for a good chunk, from what I hear. With all due honesty, they can't be all that more common than the store pets that are at the bottom of the Advents List...and I know those are all up for debate on moving up, so might be time to consider those for this?

i agree they're a pain to find as the people who buy them are typically collectors and aren't willing to trade them (?), but the ones i have gotten were actually pretty cheap (although i admit i'm 99.9% certain i underpaid for those)
trades (for all 2011 store horses):
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... v3kSkcoOlg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4eUg8fXVuA
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GAVY-48LKg
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L9WDRYNeBQ
the natural colored arabs/clydesdale (i assume they're what you mean by early 2011) that i have i definitely underpaid for during the halloween event, so it's hard to say. on the other hand, i don't think people would pay low advents for one.
sorry if this is all speculation- i don't have a lot of experience trading dogs, so i can't really compare their values ;____;

edit: just went through the thread again and found posts on this, woops. but yes, 2009 to 2010 rare sounds approximately right

[DaDwarf]

The horses are worth about an early 09 rare right now i believe. But in sets, i've traded em for mid-advent + before. So i personally do think they should be added on this list, maybe just on the bottom line?

[DerbyGirl]

I was thinking bottom line as well, so totally agree. :3 I can't post any trades, since I got all of mine back in early '11 xD

[DaDwarf]

Dark Faced October, Watermelon, Yin Yang Green Swirl, Royal Bobtail, Grown White Scarf dog, Blue Snowflake Scarf dog, Dark Wood Dog

Blue Spotted, Blue Light Stripe, Orange Light Stripe, Orange Heavy Stripe, Red Heavy Stripe, Red Spotted, Light Faced October, Pink Moon, Chocolate Bun, Lilac Bun, Black Dutch Bun, Grey Dutch Bun, august rats??

Orange Spotted, Blue Heavy Stripe, Red Light Stripe, Brown Moon Dog, Light Faced PPS, Dark Faced PPS, Mismatched Green Swirl, Pointy Pink Pastel, Raccoon rat

Floppy Pink Pastel, Floppy Green Pastel, Royal Swirl, Queen of Hearts, King of Diamonds, King of Spades, Queen of Clubs, Spiderwing Bwolf, Pumpkin bwolf,The 08 christmas rats* , Camo Dog

Blue Moon Dog, , 3 Tailed Pastel,

2011 store horses

*Please note, the elf rat, the santa rat and the reindeer rat are on the advents list.

Oke so i moved the camo dog up one bit, i still don't feel like it should be there lol. And then the 2011 store horses on there as well.

[Amethysts]

The horses are worth about an early 09 rare right now i believe. But in sets, i've traded em for mid-advent + before. So i personally do think they should be added on this list, maybe just on the bottom line?

I see the horses go for 2 '09 rares.

[Dragon Documentary]

What about the Queen of clubs '08 Very Rare and the King of Diamonds '08 Very rare? Should they be on a bottom tier somewhere?

[MasonBees]

What about the Queen of clubs '08 Very Rare and the King of Diamonds '08 Very rare? Should they be on a bottom tier somewhere?

They're on the fourth tier right now.

[brewster510]

Shima?