The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[~Fading Echo~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Bh0U4HdtLA

What should be done to make this fair? Thank you in advance

[chocolate orchids ~]

-post removed at user's request-

[ToxicLama]

Is this fair to the Angel Advent?

[cakepopcat]

Is this fair to bottom?

[Rerathar]

Is this fair to bottom?

This is at least fair, might even be an overypay!

[ceese]

ello is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5VASG_0GnA

[inkyst]

I think this is unfair to them. You need to give a lot more,i think

[Potatobaby]

is this fair ??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zx3avptMYg

[ToxicLama]

Is this fair to the Angel Advent?

[kivr & fireflii]

So so so I fell out of my knowledge of rarities for awhile. I decided I'm gonna' get back into them a bit. I'd like to think I know a decent amount, enough to generally tell if something is fair/unfair, but my problem (right now) lies with what to add/remove to make things fair (because as we all know, demand, etc. changes). Anyway, like I said, I'm trying to get back into it so... here I am! Just a note to everyone, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE make sure you ALWAYS (not even just for me, but for all advice you're given) get more than one opinion! Everyone sees things a little differently based on their knowledge and experience, and it's always reassuring to have more than one opinion in case someone is wrong/a little off/etc. c: So yes, while I'm fairly confident in most of my knowledge, please get more opinions than just mine (if you've only had mine)!
-fireflii

Is this fair? If not please tell me what I need to do to fix it :3

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OEeR4XCNVw

Thanks in advance

(Please see note at the top first!)
I believe it's unfair to you. Keep the 09 PPS, all the 09 rares, and maybe one or two '10 advents. I'd get a second opinion on that though.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=32809371&userid=283008&signature=p7aTTs35qV5k6O61M9PPgQ
Hello everyone!

Thank you c:
Do you know what they could add?

Second opinion perhaps?

(Please see note at the top first)
I'd actually say a bit unfair to them. Instead of an 09 VR, make it one or two 09 rares (get another opinion on that).

So, with this trade, which would be the best option?

~Both PPS + all other non-lists
~Grinner + all other non-lists
~Red Butterbun + all other non-lists
~Anything else?

(Please see note at the top first!)
Technically all those opinions are unfair to you. Red butterbun + all non-lists would be least... unfair... to you (if that makes sense???). The cream santa hat advent would be fair alone, but with the demand on the raven, your trading partner might not accept it. If I were you, personally, I'd try both PPS (and only + all non-lists if they don't mean anything to you, because it'd already be unfair to you).

Is this a fair trade?

(Please see note at the top first!)
If not, what needs to be added to make it fair? Thank you in advanced for the help. :)

(Please see note at the top first!)
About fair, maybe a little unfair to you. Demand isn't really high on the red-front (or the green front for that matter lol). I would definitely get a second opinion, but I'd say take out one or two 09 rares and it should be more fair (again, get another opinion!!).

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=32803915&userid=423990&signature=Pa3MjEnEe4y3Bh0U4HdtLA

What should be done to make this fair? Thank you in advance

(Please see note at the top first!)
Unfair to you. They should add early '10 rare, maybe late '09 rare depending on the pet (because the pet you have is already late 09, I think like september or something...). I'd say closer to an early early '10 rare since, in my own experience, that malk pet (even if rare) wasn't/isn't one of the more high-demand malk pets.

Anyone know? Click

(Please see note at the top first!)
I'd say about fair. May want another opinion, the advent might be just a few tiers too high to be fair, though.

Is this fair to the Angel Advent?

(Please see note at the top first!)
Unfair to bat dog

Is this fair to bottom?

(Please see note at the top first!)
Bit unfair to green tox, change the skele pps to a lower tier like wolf pps

ello is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5VASG_0GnA

(Please see note at the top first!)
Unfair to store dog, other side would need to add some older rares

is this fair ??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zx3avptMYg

(Please see note at the top first!)
Very unfair to UR flower. UR flower rarity alone is at least above the non dogs (nonjewel/nontag/etc.)
-fireflii