The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread - Please use this one!

[Applenz]

fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3CV7nsBEaQ



and


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... twq_h76zQQ


anyone know?

I believe that the top is unfair to them.

I'm not sure of the other one.

[Le Smiley the dog]

Hi
Would Cream advent + boar PPS = a Grinner?

Thanks ^^

could you show us the trade or at least pictures of these pets?

[kisawolfz]

Hi
Would Cream advent + boar PPS = a Grinner?

Thanks ^^

could you show us the trade or at least pictures of these pets?

If you dont know list pets, dont spam :3
To answer the question,
I Would say... slightly unfair to grinner.
By how much, I dont know that part.

[unikornie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... n_AmzlIzvg is this fair? anyone know?

thanks (:

[Le Smiley the dog]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30233915&userid=513337&signature=-m4C26UR1q0gn_AmzlIzvg is this fair? anyone know?

thanks (:

well i think they get more but thats just my opinion.

[beemo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30233915&userid=513337&signature=-m4C26UR1q0gn_AmzlIzvg is this fair? anyone know?

thanks (:

That's unfair to you.

[unikornie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30233915&userid=513337&signature=-m4C26UR1q0gn_AmzlIzvg is this fair? anyone know?

thanks (:

well i think they get more but thats just my opinion.

ok thanks! could just one other person share there opinion please? thanks much appreciated

[Vanhishikha]

fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3CV7nsBEaQ



and


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... twq_h76zQQ


anyone know?

First Trade: Top one would be considered unfair for the top person for they offered a Pink Patchy September. Though both pets are upon the September list, the Light Leopard, which is the pet the bottom has offered, is lower than the Pink Patchy September. Though not by much. Three rows but that could mean a lot. The bottom would need to ad perhaps another pet or something to their end to make the offer seem more fair to both sides. Also, the dates don't matter in this situation since both are re-released, even though that doesn't lower their values either.

Second Trade: I would consider it fair for the Light Leopard. The other two pets offered are on the Advent list, one is towards the mid-bottom as the other is closer to the mid-top, but I do believe them together would make it to perhaps a Drink Me or Grinners amount. Then when adding the C$ amount, it levels out a tinny but more. Almost perfect. I'd say it was a good trade.

[unikornie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=30233915&userid=513337&signature=-m4C26UR1q0gn_AmzlIzvg is this fair? anyone know?

thanks (:

That's unfair to you.

thanks for the second opinion didn't see that when I posteed my last reply! thanks!!!

[bartjs]

fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3CV7nsBEaQ



and


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... twq_h76zQQ


anyone know?

First Trade: Top one would be considered unfair for the top person for they offered a Pink Patchy September. Though both pets are upon the September list, the Light Leopard, which is the pet the bottom has offered, is lower than the Pink Patchy September. Though not by much. Three rows but that could mean a lot. The bottom would need to ad perhaps another pet or something to their end to make the offer seem more fair to both sides. Also, the dates don't matter in this situation since both are re-released, even though that doesn't lower their values either.

Second Trade: I would consider it fair for the Light Leopard. The other two pets offered are on the Advent list, one is towards the mid-bottom as the other is closer to the mid-top, but I do believe them together would make it to perhaps a Drink Me or Grinners amount. Then when adding the C$ amount, it levels out a tinny but more. Almost perfect. I'd say it was a good trade.

Ok thanks and i canceled the first cause i don't want to feel like a scammer XD the other me and him/her are making a deal with some pets. so its all good thanks!