The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[Jaskiest]

Is this fair? The animal egg is worth a mid '12 uncommon and is from Easter 2012, if that helps ^o^ Thanks!

^Anyone have any idea about this? Thanks!^

[alchemist.]

Could someone please help me rate all of these from best to worst?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DqP0tRgtKg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AVvKa_Ut0A

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 93MDdjmiWg


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... KkEIamgKxw

I know. I'd just like to know witch one should be rated one two and three.

They are all overpay. The August PPS isn't worth more than an 2011 rare, or a few 2012 rares, or a a couple of 2010 Uncommons.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

This might be a little more of a complicated question, but how many of these PPS lines would equal a blue balloon? ^^"


May I please get an answer that excludes the rare ones and one that includes them? ^^"

Any help would be greatly appreciated! c:

εїз----------------------------------------------------------------
{this is tough. hmmm
so lemme just list all the pps of those lines.
dice pps worth a mid advent
buckskin pps worth a low advent
an april 2010 uncommon [indian pony]
an october 2010 uncommon [bay]
an october 2010 rare [dapple grey]
that seems to be about it

okay so I'm gonna do just the uncommon ones, then just the rare ones and then just the list ones. is that okay?

-uncommons-
quantity is hard. but I'd say a low main list could get 400-600 of them

-rares-
so just the one rare.
I'd say about 200

-list ones-
could get 20 of just the dice pps.
probably about 30 or so of just the buckskin

these are rough estimates ^^
----------------------------------------------------------------εїз

[stripez]

Is this fair?

[ThatCoffeeBoi]

This might be a little more of a complicated question, but how many of these PPS lines would equal a blue balloon? ^^"


May I please get an answer that excludes the rare ones and one that includes them? ^^"

Any help would be greatly appreciated! c:

εїз----------------------------------------------------------------
{this is tough. hmmm
so lemme just list all the pps of those lines.
dice pps worth a mid advent
buckskin pps worth a low advent
an april 2010 uncommon [indian pony]
an october 2010 uncommon [bay]
an october 2010 rare [dapple grey]
that seems to be about it

okay so I'm gonna do just the uncommon ones, then just the rare ones and then just the list ones. is that okay?

-uncommons-
quantity is hard. but I'd say a low main list could get 400-600 of them

-rares-
so just the one rare.
I'd say about 200

-list ones-
could get 20 of just the dice pps.
probably about 30 or so of just the buckskin

these are rough estimates ^^
----------------------------------------------------------------εїз

OMG, you are my life saver. Thank you for answering! ^^ These are wonderful. :3 Thank you for the help! ^^ <3

[Tiger;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JoWNOaunjg

would this be fair? If not, what should be added or taken away?

[Patch.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29946265&userid=255752&signature=szd7-CbSTZQxJoWNOaunjg

would this be fair? If not, what should be added or taken away?

Unfair to them.

[Minimetoo]

Can I please have some help on this trade? Thank you anyone for the help!

I would say unfair to the Coontail since 1. The UR Pot has bad demand 2. People trade it off for a Non-Ballon or even a high September lists and with the toxic added together it's worth a Non or lower I say.

I thought the flower's worth was at a non? Can I get another opinion on this?

[jinixe]

Fair?
I think so!

[connoisseur]

Hi! Was this fair for the VR rare Malk horse? Thanks!