The "is this a fair trade?" thread - New thread!

[JuniperFalls]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 569WB8FyFQ
Is this fair?
Thanks in advance ^.^

[Adonis]

Is this fair?

~thanks!

unfair to the toixic if i recall correctly

[Adonis]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29804841&userid=358151&signature=NMJWZzx9Myvi569WB8FyFQ
Is this fair?
Thanks in advance ^.^

I'd say the unfair to the dragon , but get a second opinion as i just came back from a hiatus

[IvyBlack]

Is this fair? ^^

[ziggy.stardust]

What could they add to make this fair? Thank you to anyone who can help c:

[Tealclover]

The trade
Is this fair? Thanks.

[Adonis]

Is this fair? ^^

I'd say slightly unfair to the tribal

[broccoli_guardian]

an item trade - the other user sent the trade, but accepted with the message "????"
Can somebody tell me, if it wasn't fair? Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UP67C03JWg

[Adonis]

an item trade - the other user sent the trade, but accepted with the message "????"
Can somebody tell me, if it wasn't fair? Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UP67C03JWg

Unfair to top if my memory serves , however im just started to item trades so get a second opinion

[tawnypelt3]

an item trade - the other user sent the trade, but accepted with the message "????"
Can somebody tell me, if it wasn't fair? Thank you.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... UP67C03JWg

Unfair to top if my memory serves , however im just started to item trades so get a second opinion

Very unfair to the top. The galaxy dog plushie alone would be fair. And what's with the organization of the trade? The animal egg and fishbowl pebbles were released before the rose pin. ._. Is something broken?

The trade
Is this fair? Thanks.

Unfair to them. 2 commons =/= uncommon.

Rarity math is not correct, but I would say 4 commons at the very least.

What could they add to make this fair? Thank you to anyone who can help c:

I'd say that tier is worth 6ish mixed-month 2009 rares. The Shima longtail does not count as more than perhaps an early-mid 2009 rare, so they should add about 4 more.