The "is this a fair trade?" thread - New thread!

[tawnypelt3]

Hi Everyone! I've gotten good advice here in the past and I'm hoping one of you might be so kind as to help me out again.

I've got a re-release 2008 Tess horse up for trade and received this offer. Does this look fair enough to you guys?

Thank you very much for your time and have a great day!

It's unfair to them.

Agreed. Take off the first horse, the yellow and green one.

Is this fair?
1994
Also, Is this fair? If not what needs to be added? Thanks in advance for any help!

Both are unfair to you. Not sure what can be added though.

Agreed. They need to add a lot more. Like, lots more rares.

[Silverstream94]

I am trying to paperclip to get a liontail, is this a tradeup?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D-pbZWxqUw

Thank you in advance

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Hi Everyone! I've gotten good advice here in the past and I'm hoping one of you might be so kind as to help me out again.

I've got a re-release 2008 Tess horse up for trade and received this offer. Does this look fair enough to you guys?

Thank you very much for your time and have a great day!

It's unfair to them.

Agreed. Take off the first horse, the yellow and green one.

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
they'd need to take off more than that.
three of those horses/ponies can come off and a few uncommons can be added [2010-late 09]
the tess hrose was available for an extended period of time and only worth a midish 09 rare.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

[~ Castiel ~]

I have many rares from this year, 1 advent BMD bun and 3 grinners. what would be a fair offer for a winged wood angel/ advent?

[Angelsofthesky]

Hi Everyone! I've gotten good advice here in the past and I'm hoping one of you might be so kind as to help me out again.

I've got a re-release 2008 Tess horse up for trade and received this offer. Does this look fair enough to you guys?

Thank you very much for your time and have a great day!

It's unfair to them.

Agreed. Take off the first horse, the yellow and green one.

Is this fair?
1994
Also, Is this fair? If not what needs to be added? Thanks in advance for any help!

Both are unfair to you. Not sure what can be added though.

Agreed. They need to add a lot more. Like, lots more rares.

Acctually, I Think the first one is fair

[resque]

I am trying to paperclip to get a liontail, is this a tradeup?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D-pbZWxqUw

Thank you in advance

Technically. :3 Since dogs are usually valued more than butterwolves, you get a species tradeup. Since that dog they're offering was around for a long time, it's valued at a mid 09' rare, which is equal to the worth of your butterwolf.

[Silverstream94]

I am trying to paperclip to get a liontail, is this a tradeup?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D-pbZWxqUw

Thank you in advance

Technically. :3 Since dogs are usually valued more than butterwolves, you get a species tradeup. Since that dog they're offering was around for a long time, it's valued at a mid 09' rare, which is equal to the worth of your butterwolf.

Thank you ^w^

[Hyensa]

This? Thank you.

[resque]

This? Thank you.

Fair.

[ChickenSmoothieCats!]

I this fair? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BGShah-4LQ
Please help!!