The "is this a fair trade?" thread - New thread!

[Username Unknown]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=29410563&userid=516972&signature=XbNJ4IMz0h_i4nzdweby9Q

Definitely fair. I have both Aztecs and yours turned rare, their mismatch eyed one was rare for longer.

[northern downpour ;;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _MrnN3PORw
This is fair, right?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

If you could rate all of these Bids for my Dog-tag, how would you rate them (1-10 only please)?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6

Thanks in advance ^^

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bid 1 - 6
Bid 2 - 8
Bid 3 - 1
Bid 4 - 4
Bid 5 - 1
Bid 6 - 8 [technically overpay, but c$ is hard to get full value on sometimes]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

[zee99]

If you could rate all of these Bids for my Dog-tag, how would you rate them (1-10 only please)?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6

Thanks in advance ^^

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bid 1 - 6
Bid 2 - 8
Bid 3 - 1
Bid 4 - 4
Bid 5 - 1
Bid 6 - 8 [technically overpay, but c$ is hard to get full value on sometimes]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

Could I have some explanation on why Bid 5 is so low? Just out of curiosity.

[Sappy]

If you could rate all of these Bids for my Dog-tag, how would you rate them (1-10 only please)?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6

Thanks in advance ^^

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bid 1 - 6
Bid 2 - 8
Bid 3 - 1
Bid 4 - 4
Bid 5 - 1
Bid 6 - 8 [technically overpay, but c$ is hard to get full value on sometimes]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

Could I have some explanation on why Bid 5 is so low? Just out of curiosity.

There's No Mainlist pets.

[Missing-One]

Does anyone know what would make this fair? As in, what are the items worth? I tried asking the what is this item worth thread but I wasn't having much luck there. I hope it's okay if I ask here.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

If you could rate all of these Bids for my Dog-tag, how would you rate them (1-10 only please)?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6

Thanks in advance ^^

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bid 1 - 6
Bid 2 - 8
Bid 3 - 1
Bid 4 - 4
Bid 5 - 1
Bid 6 - 8 [technically overpay, but c$ is hard to get full value on sometimes]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

Could I have some explanation on why Bid 5 is so low? Just out of curiosity.

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
the whole bid isnt worth more than above the gap and honestly, anything that isnt worth even a third of the dogtag I ranked very low.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

[zee99]

quote="Spencer."]

If you could rate all of these Bids for my Dog-tag, how would you rate them (1-10 only please)?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6

Thanks in advance ^^

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bid 1 - 6
Bid 2 - 8
Bid 3 - 1
Bid 4 - 4
Bid 5 - 1
Bid 6 - 8 [technically overpay, but c$ is hard to get full value on sometimes]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

Could I have some explanation on why Bid 5 is so low? Just out of curiosity.

There's No Mainlist pets.

[/quote]
The UR Purple horse is on the mainlist...

@trouble, Hm, I didn't realize I was that far off this time... what would make it fair?

[Sappy]

If you could rate all of these Bids for my Dog-tag, how would you rate them (1-10 only please)?

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6

Thanks in advance ^^

εїз-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Bid 1 - 6
Bid 2 - 8
Bid 3 - 1
Bid 4 - 4
Bid 5 - 1
Bid 6 - 8 [technically overpay, but c$ is hard to get full value on sometimes]
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------εїз

Could I have some explanation on why Bid 5 is so low? Just out of curiosity

There's No Mainlist pets, but the Purple Horse.

Sorry I Missed the horse, But trouble is right, it's no where near the rank of the Dogtag.

[zee99]

What could I add to make it fair? ^^