The "is this a fair trade?" thread [notice 2nd post]

[artem]

Alright last one I swear XD http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28867956&userid=118141&signature=spTxdIAQ4fbyLzE1ozmfBw Fair?

[Ashki]

The trade is unfair to you. As for the second question, it depends on which 2011 store pet you'd like, as some are more sought after than others, and some have more demand. It also depends what pets you're offering. ^^

Thank you all again. I added a warrior cat to the other trade, and I'm quite happy with that.

The trade is this . What should I have added to this if its not fair?

That looks fair to me, considering the 2011 store pets is a pretty late one. ^^

[Pomme De Terre]

Alright last one I swear XD http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28867956&userid=118141&signature=spTxdIAQ4fbyLzE1ozmfBw Fair?

Unfair to top

[Ashki]

Alright last one I swear XD http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28867956&userid=118141&signature=spTxdIAQ4fbyLzE1ozmfBw Fair?

Unfair to top

Agreed. ^^

[shikanta17]

1994

I got these for my auction and was wondering which is more fair? Also on #2, is part 1 alone fair or does it have to have part 2? Since it's for an auction I'd like to get at least 2 opinions. Thank you everyone for your help so far and thanks in advance to anyone else that helps

#1

#2 Part 1+Part 2

#3

#1 They are overpaying.
#2 I'm unsure with the quantity.
#3 Very unfair to you

If anyof those peta arent on the lists in #1, its unfair to C$

The rat is the Lime Ice Rat, it's on the September List, in the higher tiers.

Thank you all for your help!

On bid #2 the are 44 pets in total, so if that helps for advice I'd really appreciate a second opinion

Edit: I auto-ed #1 and got This as bid #4 it has 82 pets

[Missing-One]

Thanks guys!

[Ashki]

1994

I got these for my auction and was wondering which is more fair? Also on #2, is part 1 alone fair or does it have to have part 2? Since it's for an auction I'd like to get at least 2 opinions. Thank you everyone for your help so far and thanks in advance to anyone else that helps :D

#1

#2 Part 1+Part 2

#3

#1 They are overpaying.
#2 I'm unsure with the quantity.
#3 Very unfair to you

If anyof those peta arent on the lists in #1, its unfair to C$

The rat is the Lime Ice Rat, it's on the September List, in the higher tiers.

Thank you all for your help!

On bid #2 the are 44 pets in total, so if that helps for advice I'd really appreciate a second opinion :D

Edit: I auto-ed #1 and got This as bid #4 it has 82 pets

I'd say #2 is a bit hard to tell, because if you price each pet, an early 09 rare/very rare ranging from January to April is worth between 35 and 40C$, a mid 09 rare/very rare ranging from May to August is worth between 30 and 35C$ and a late 09 rare/very rare ranging from September to December is worth between 25-30C$. And then an early 2010 rare/very rare ranging from January to April is worth around 25C$, a mid 2010 rare/very rare ranging from May to August is worth around 20C$, and a late 2010 rare/very rare ranging from September to December is worth around 15+C$. But if you go by the lists 200C$ is a september pet, and those pets don't add up to a September. So I suppose it depends on how you look at it, but ultimately I'd say unfair to the C$. Bid #4 is unfair to the C$.

[cloudStriker]

hi guys is this fair demand wise??
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LdV0CR8zoA
I need an answer quick!
thanks a lot if you help

[ashby.]

I asked about this the other night, and I was wondering if I could get some more help

viewtopic.php?f=40&t=1735385&p=59622024#p59622024
This is the link to my auction thread, current with 19 bids although I think 1 was cancelled. Anyway if you are willing to help me pick the best bid, please pm me. I am not very good at rarities. Thank you in advance

[asriel]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28750820&userid=296087&signature=_oaS3KhD48FjYxLGlWl1gw

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=28873327&userid=296087&signature=Km7lSBCXtwG3R6gAGsDopg

Also this?