"The" Rares List Guide - Do not ask about new UR's!

[dakotapaws]

Why is the evil PPS on the list an the good/ice isn't?

Because people want the Evil PPS more than they want the Good/ice.

The rares list takes many things into consideration not just littermates and rarity tags.

I know that I was just curious XD

[quietude]

Would a dark leopard get a red rosé and Ba?

No, it's only worth a BA. As you can see, they're both on the top line of the september's list- that means they're equal in value. You'd have to add quite a bit more to get the red rose.

If you consider demand, you'd have to add some more 'cause some people are willing to pay crazy prices for one.

[Fuzzeh]

Would a dark leopard get a red rosé and Ba?

No, it's only worth a BA. As you can see, they're both on the top line of the september's list- that means they're equal in value. You'd have to add quite a bit more to get the red rose.

If you consider demand, you'd have to add some more 'cause some people are willing to pay crazy prices for one.

The list already takes demand into account. If you add more demand on top of it, then you're just making yourself pay more for no reason.

[nickjr]

Why is the evil PPS on the list an the good/ice isn't?

Because people want the Evil PPS more than they want the Good/ice.

The rares list takes many things into consideration not just littermates and rarity tags.

In addition, I believe the evil PPS was actually rarer (as in actual calculated rarity, ignoring demand).

[Hekomi]

yes the evil PPS went VR way before the good one.

[DaDwarf]

Check page 4!

[nickjr]

o: Looks nice!

One thing that bothers me, though (but it's not very important):

[snip]

Key:
Non-dog = non swirl/tag/coon NOT non-jewel
Sorbet = any colour
Dark Leopard = High September
Red Rose = Mid September
Grinner = Low September
CEG = Clear Eyed Galaxy
Grown White Scarf Dog tier = Lowest Advent
Mini Husky tier = Low Advent
Grey Border Collie tier = Mid Advent
Sock Dog tier = High Advent

[snip]

In the key, you started listing the pets from most valuable and then decreasing in value, and then suddenly, you jump to the bottom of the Advents list and start climbing up. I suspect that people who don't read carefully might think that a scarf dog is higher on the list than the sock dog but will later get confused as to why the sock dog is higher. xD

[Hekomi]

oops. I can fix that.

[The Great ME!]

Just a thought/question I had.

I assume that this is staying way back here into the hundreds-pages because it's still being discussed/finalized and you probably just don't want to add a bunch of confusion about values before it's done and agreed upon, but will it eventually be on the front/main page? Where it's more easily found and accessible?
It just becomes a little tedious when posts get further to have to click through a bunch of other pages to find the page that those are on xD For those of us already trying to put it to use and figure out trade fairness for ourselves

Or perhaps at least do a "Copy Shortcut" [url] link to the specific post on the front page?

Also I think the BA/Joker dogs should be valued by their actual worth because going by demand is just going to make people ask more for them as the "Norm" than they're actually worth. AGAIN.
And some people think that Joker Dogs are worth mid-Gap's and such which is ridiculous. Next thing you know they'll be asking for them to be worth the value of a Sunjewel, if this keeps up.
As it is the BA shouldn't even be on the Septembers List at all if you take into account it's actual worth vs. Demand, it should be Advent list, and the Joker should already be lower too, as I heard from Trouble many times over when we've talked about it.
I'm sure it's been said before already tons of times, but just adding my vote to the proverbial voting pot ;P if it makes any difference

[Hekomi]

you're right, since it's still a draft it's not on the front yet. c: