The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[Yoloswagger]

this fair? please tell me! c: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Uvz9TCWQew

Unfair to you

thanks! what should be changed?

[Turtle Shoes]

Are either of these fair? I just got this from the pound and have been swamped with trades!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26838581&userid=161587&signature=wtBdXDEFak7S_JFlq9rssA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26839049&userid=161587&signature=GG_xqKC34sCC3QqC_PgmTw

I don't think I want to trade it yet but I just wanted an opinion so I know just how rare it actually is.

[FireOmens]

this fair? please tell me! c: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Uvz9TCWQew

It's very unfair to you, possibly get your trading partner to add a few more rares. ^^
~Faith

[Lizord]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26837346&userid=396044&signature=e-kKgyMnCdVC45tufPvS7A
Fair?^^ I dont know if those rares and items are enough to close the gap between the Skeleton PPS and WWA .

I'm going to say unfair to the bottom but I'm not really sure so please get a second opinion[/quote]

Thanks^^ Second opinion please?

[p!atd]

Well, my COPPA'd friend, Continuum, got an offer on her Re-Release Red X Cat (originally released Christmas '09)

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=7AC9553EDB7B656D56C95099BBAF13F6&bg=99c57c

and her Green Oil Paint Dog (February 2011 Uncommon)

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=E34D9397B3E373ED5226FEACE0EF3C54&bg=99c57c

and did some research and found it was worth a late '09 rare.

The offer she got was a Fruit Salad Dog (May 2010 rare):

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=5CCB42A5BBC21C624AB947AA4B2561B3&bg=99c57c

a Blue/Red BW (May 2010 Uncommon):

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=C0B9BCB5CE9340EE474D9AFD1B4F866E&bg=99c57c

a Grey Tabby Rat (May 2010 Uncommon):

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=6838E420465E9401BCBA32E2752BAD70&bg=99c57c

a Snow Leopard PPS (June 2010 Uncommon):

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=C6E62DA16C6446ADE9DFF48BBB8600C1&bg=99c57c

a Three-Tailed/Light Pink Flitter (July 2010 Uncommon):

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=1E32288227F24AA6B760802D17B8378C&bg=99c57c

a Slecouth Staff Dog (November 2010 Uncommon):

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=293A63055F23B9B0DB573554B9E2592F&bg=99c57c

and the Snowcap Hummerwolf (May 2013, unknown)

http://static.chickensmoothie.com/archive/image.php?k=F1A4A6F059AFAB04EFB2410A031CAD71&bg=99c57c



Yes, this will be a very long post, but, is it fair?
All of the pets were wishlist on both sides, if that makes a difference.

Thank you in advance for taking the time to help us!

[Violet2sweet]

I want a few more opinions is this fair for me? I prefer if you tell me if its overtrade for which person
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d1AdiCDpSg

[♥Sterek♥]

I want a few more opinions is this fair for me? I prefer if you tell me if its overtrade for which person
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... d1AdiCDpSg

Its unfair to them. a sorbet is worth 4x a balloon dog and this is 1 and 1/3 or something probably less.

[pockypo]

is this a fair trade?

Really want that BMD, but not sure I have the fodder for it. xD
Thanks to anyone who helps <3

EDIT : just to help you guys out...

BMD for

late 2008 / early 2009 :
- 2 November 2008 rare rats
- 3 January 2009 rare dogs
- 2 January 2009 rare rats
- 2 January 2009 very rare rats
- 1 February 2009 rare dog
- 1 February 2009 rare Malk horse
- 3 February 2009 rare rats
- 1 March 2009 rare bwolf
- 4 March 2009 rare rats
- 3 April 2009 rare rats
- 1 April 2009 rare spider

mid 2009 :
- 1 May 2009 rare dog
- 2 May 2009 rare rats
- 1 May 2009 very rare bwolf
- 1 June 2009 rare spider
- 2 June 2009 rare rats

late 2009 :
- 1 September 2009 rare rat

mid 2010 :
- 1 June 2010 rare Equimagine pony

early 2011 :
- 1 April 2011 rare dog

early 2012 :
- 4 April 2012 rare bwolves

mid 2012 :
- 1 July 2012 rare bwolf

late 2012 :
- 1 October 2012 rare bat
- 3 October 2012 rare Yulynh horses

sorry the list is so long x.x

Isn't it unfair to the bottom? That just looks like major overpay. ._." Get a second opinion though...

hahahah i wasn't sure myself. xDD
it seemed like a lot, then again, i've payed for so much for other september lists on a lower tier that i'm just not sure.
but anyway, thanks for your input <33

any second opinions?

[Lap Sinja]

Hello!
Is this a fair trade?

I've before only traded Rares with C$, so i've no idea for lower rarities.

[jinixe]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5BnfDNb3nw


This one i'm lost on...Thank you ahead of time ^-^