The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[nymphadora.]

Fair or unfair and to whom?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... V4_XHy2a0Q

[pockypo]

is this a fair trade?

Really want that BMD, but not sure I have the fodder for it. xD
Thanks to anyone who helps <3

EDIT : just to help you guys out...

BMD for

late 2008 / early 2009 :
- 2 November 2008 rare rats
- 3 January 2009 rare dogs
- 2 January 2009 rare rats
- 2 January 2009 very rare rats
- 1 February 2009 rare dog
- 1 February 2009 rare Malk horse
- 3 February 2009 rare rats
- 1 March 2009 rare bwolf
- 4 March 2009 rare rats
- 3 April 2009 rare rats
- 1 April 2009 rare spider

mid 2009 :
- 1 May 2009 rare dog
- 2 May 2009 rare rats
- 1 May 2009 very rare bwolf
- 1 June 2009 rare spider
- 2 June 2009 rare rats

late 2009 :
- 1 September 2009 rare rat

mid 2010 :
- 1 June 2010 rare Equimagine pony

early 2011 :
- 1 April 2011 rare dog

early 2012 :
- 4 April 2012 rare bwolves

mid 2012 :
- 1 July 2012 rare bwolf

late 2012 :
- 1 October 2012 rare bat
- 3 October 2012 rare Yulynh horses

sorry the list is so long x.x

[MenheraCollie]

is this trade fair? Thank you! ^^

unfair.
But try to get second opinion.

Unfair to bottom.

thank you ^^

[lucky333123]

From what i've seen Re-releases are of lesser value, I would add at least two to three more rares on the purple toxic's side.

That's not true re-releases are worth the exactly same value as the original creature. It is just that some users prefer true date ones compared to re-released ones.

[Vraska the Unseen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zhDFPyJlPA For green Gragon

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... JzOYBiahfw King of hearts Lion

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gnSdK3HzTQ Monster dog

More bids, my brain is being stupid with these.

[Minimetoo]

is this trade fair? Thank you! ^^

Unfair to you.

Thank you for the help!

Here is an edited version-
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GDDyyjNtoA

Actually, I believe that's unfair to you. But get a second opinion.
/quote]

Thank you!

Could I possibly have a second opinion? I want to keep this as fair as possible.

I agree. Unfair to you.

Is this fair?

I'd say unfair to you. But please get another opinion before accepting/cancelling the trade, I could be wrong. ^^
~Free

Can I get any other help?

I would say unfair, the green toxic is of high demand, but it's a re-release.[/quote]
Thanks, but i believe re-releases have same value, what would be needed to add to their side/my side?[/quote]

Rereleased pets do have the same value. I do believe that's unfair to the top actually, but I'm not sure what exactly could be added.

[senpai]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26839532&userid=427767&signature=21ZJ8ioq8O6AjyDXkhM-SQ

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... LOhgGr5IPg

Any help would be loved ^^

[Unseen~Before]

The trade changed again

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... F-9ZoeU24w

Fair?

[nymphadora.]

Fair or unfair and to whom?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... V4_XHy2a0Q

[Gratefultritone]

is this a fair trade?

Really want that BMD, but not sure I have the fodder for it. xD
Thanks to anyone who helps <3

EDIT : just to help you guys out...

BMD for

late 2008 / early 2009 :
- 2 November 2008 rare rats
- 3 January 2009 rare dogs
- 2 January 2009 rare rats
- 2 January 2009 very rare rats
- 1 February 2009 rare dog
- 1 February 2009 rare Malk horse
- 3 February 2009 rare rats
- 1 March 2009 rare bwolf
- 4 March 2009 rare rats
- 3 April 2009 rare rats
- 1 April 2009 rare spider

mid 2009 :
- 1 May 2009 rare dog
- 2 May 2009 rare rats
- 1 May 2009 very rare bwolf
- 1 June 2009 rare spider
- 2 June 2009 rare rats

late 2009 :
- 1 September 2009 rare rat

mid 2010 :
- 1 June 2010 rare Equimagine pony

early 2011 :
- 1 April 2011 rare dog

early 2012 :
- 4 April 2012 rare bwolves

mid 2012 :
- 1 July 2012 rare bwolf

late 2012 :
- 1 October 2012 rare bat
- 3 October 2012 rare Yulynh horses

sorry the list is so long x.x

Isn't it unfair to the bottom? That just looks like major overpay. ._." Get a second opinion though...