The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[nyacinth]

Hi guys. Im no good at September list trading and i just got an offer saying that she would like to know what i would offer for a light leopard and a peppermint eared. I have a light heart rat, would that do or would I have to add some more pets? Please, can only experienced players answer this ^^

answered ^^

[RoxieLover12]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... DMmDa7bTlw Can someone tell me why this bid is unfair?

[Puddin_Pie]

Is this fair?

If not what needs to be done?

I would say unfair to you, because the Wolf PPS is on the Main Rares List.

Anyone else? what needs to be done?

[-_____-]

If I was looking to trade-up, what would be some nice, yet fair boosters for this group and this one?

[KathrynKat]

DogTag for Grevy's Zebra should I take the chance or no because... Just suddenly the Zebra's Demand is almost jumping into it's place (people try to offer just nontag or under saying it's NOT worth anything above or right under).
Also I feel after the line art change it may get more demand like the Unicorns had no demand but for the Pink Rare

so again
DogTag for Grevy's (Grevy's is Tier above DogTag)

[Sabu]

Is this a good auto for a quantity auction?The Zodiac dogs are boosters.<3

[Sabu]

Ignore this >o<

[Wyvern Queen Kym]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26526348&userid=416790&signature=p6cMPUT4W_DuQLPVrZE5sw

Is this fair, both demand and rarity wise?

Reposting this due to lack of response...thanks guys for when you can answer. =)

Rarity wise unfair to top but demand wise the warrior cats have way better demand than rats

Thanks a bunch. =)

[hellebore]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 42yeVKcvLw
How can I make this fair if this is unfair? Thank you!

[-TheBigBlueBear-]

How fair is this trade?
I know about an apple needs to be added to a GWJ to be fair to a nontag. But from the apple you would have to add to get up to the balloon ^^" <3

Thanks for your advice <3
Please make sure you are experienced if you're going to answer this question ^^ <3
- Cole