The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice 2nd post]

[daybreak.]

Thanks to Daybreak and Patch :mrgreen: Does anyone know when they will ' edit' the list ? They do that once a year right ? :mrgreen:

I can't really answer your question, but I'd say they're planning on bumping the joker down and not up:

The Joker bubble has never burst; I see no reason why it would after all this time. Part of me thinks perhaps it ought to be removed from the Rares List and put into a category of its own - listed at its rarity (mid September I think, it went VR with the floppy pink if I recall correctly) and just given a note that due to high demand it goes for main list pets. Then let the community decide how much they pay for it; heck knows it's what they are doing now anyway.

we need to clarify whether we will be valuing the joker by demand or its true value

They haven't decided yet, but it's being discussed, just saying ;3

[heartsong]

Can I please get help ranking these bids? I'm looking for a couple different opinions.
Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7

[Birdy]

What would need to be added to a UR Aussie in order to be fair to a Coontail?
I know the UR Aussie isn't on the Rares List yet, so I understand it's just an estimate. Thanks in advance.

~teddyrosa

[Puddin_Pie]

Is this better? Do I need to add more or take some off?

Still unfair to you

Thanks, any idea what I should add? Would this make it fair?

[Final_Gamer]

Fair or unfair to which side?

[Kex.]

Can I please get help ranking these bids? I'm looking for a couple different opinions.
Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7

Well, the first one's a high-advent, so that's alot of overpay on their side since the Patchwork is just a mid-avent.
The second one is fair, both of the pets are on the same tier.
The third one's unfair, the Ornament PPS is a few tiers lower.
The fourth one is overpaying even more than the first bid, 90 C$ = highest tier on Advent list, so the extra rares are also overpay.
Fifth one's also overpay, the Seal PPS is three tiers higher.
The sixth one is also obviously overpay, since it also has a Seal PPS plus a bunch of rares.
And the last one is way overpaying, the rat is a mid-September.

So all in all, the best offer would be the 7th Bid.

[heartsong]

Can I please get help ranking these bids? I'm looking for a couple different opinions.
Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7

Well, the first one's a high-advent, so that's alot of overpay on their side since the Patchwork is just a mid-avent.
The second one is fair, both of the pets are on the same tier.
The third one's unfair, the Ornament PPS is a few tiers lower.
The fourth one is overpaying even more than the first bid, 90 C$ = highest tier on Advent list, so the extra rares are also overpay.
Fifth one's also overpay, the Seal PPS is three tiers higher.
The sixth one is also obviously overpay, since it also has a Seal PPS plus a bunch of rares.
And the last one is way overpaying, the rat is a mid-September.

So all in all, the best offer would be the 7th Bid.

ok thanks

[Angelsofthesky]

Thanks to Daybreak and Patch Does anyone know when they will ' edit' the list ? They do that once a year right ?

I can't really answer your question, but I'd say they're planning on bumping the joker down and not up:

The Joker bubble has never burst; I see no reason why it would after all this time. Part of me thinks perhaps it ought to be removed from the Rares List and put into a category of its own - listed at its rarity (mid September I think, it went VR with the floppy pink if I recall correctly) and just given a note that due to high demand it goes for main list pets. Then let the community decide how much they pay for it; heck knows it's what they are doing now anyway.

we need to clarify whether we will be valuing the joker by demand or its true value

They haven't decided yet, but it's being discussed, just saying ;3

But someone just say they were planning on taking it to part one? Um okay... New info *taking in* thanks

[-TheBigBlueBear-]

How fair is this trade?
I know about an apple needs to be added to a GWJ to be fair to a nontag. But from the apple you would have to add to get up to the balloon ^^" <3

Thanks for your advice <3
Please make sure you are experienced if you're going to answer this question ^^ <3
- Cole

[hellebore]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=26520461&userid=258790&signature=vX05hREJt1c842yeVKcvLw
How can I make this fair if this is unfair? Thank you!