The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 740]

[Shian]

These are both 2008 rares. Would they be worth a list pet if I auctioned them together? And if so, can someone give me an example of the tier I should be looking at? Please and thank you. (:

No they are not.

[Catheren]

Malk PPS + Brown Sleipnir = 2 Mid Advents?

Also this: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... L87VkrC33g

Getting a second opinoon! Thanks in advance

[Butter Dragon]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MrLC_Afvew
Is this fair? ^^

[RedAutumnLeaf]

How big is the gap between the Winged Blood Dog and the Angel Advent?

(It can be in advents, Septembers, or just plain rares)

Thank you to anyone who helps me. ^^

(Oh, and @Hyena, that trade is unfair to them. Although Warriors have good demand, I'd say they are overpaying.)

[Doodles]

These are both 2008 rares. Would they be worth a list pet if I auctioned them together? And if so, can someone give me an example of the tier I should be looking at? Please and thank you. (:

No they are not.

actually wouldn't it be worth around the bottum teir of thr advent list? Seeing as 3 early 09' rafes equal to the bottum tier, their from Obctober 08'.. So, would that not equal bottum tier or so?

[~wolf~spirit~]

Is this fair? If not what should be changed? Thanks in advance

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _or0yZdStA

Technically unfair for you, but with demand I think its about fair.

^ I have no idea, sorry.

Second opinion please? Thanks in advance

[Shian]

These are both 2008 rares. Would they be worth a list pet if I auctioned them together? And if so, can someone give me an example of the tier I should be looking at? Please and thank you. (:

No they are not.

actually wouldn't it be worth around the bottum teir of thr advent list? Seeing as 3 early 09' rafes equal to the bottum tier, their from Obctober 08'.. So, would that not equal bottum tier or so?

No. If the two pets being auctioned were a harder to find pet like the watermellon dog, heavy orange stripe or a grown halo maybe you could get a bottom advent, but there's so many 08s that are rarer and harder to come by than these two.

09s can't even be used as an example in this situation because 09s had adoption limits. These guys don't. It's why advents are worth more than Oct 08s in the first place.
Maybe you could find someone wanting those enough to pay an advent for it but it would be unfair to them.

[nekolover19]

Okay, I'm here again for advice based on demand.
Bid
What do you think?

[Vazchu]

I've apparently forgotten to ask about a offer I got last weekend...

How does this look to you guys? Fair or not?
To me it looks like it's far too much on their side of the trade, but then again, I've no idea how much the guiena pigs are worth nor how highly desired they are compared to other pets (and the person might have added that much to their side because the guiena pig is one of their dreamies)...

[Duck2900]

Sunback+CEG=UR Butterfly? If not what should be added