The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 740]

[Cartier]

Ok, I'm going to ask one more thing about my lion now, I already got the reply that [ this ] is unfair to me (I'm guessing demand-wise?). And apparently the lion is one of the dreamies that this person has (and the spider is one of my dreamies), so it would be nice to be able to work something out with them... So the question is, exactly how unfair is the trade?

And then a person gave me an offer on my mint horse. Surely there's a lot of pets on their side that I'm not interested in (like the horses, guinea pig, blue fox(?) and the lions), but still... I've no idea what the Shima dog and the black dog with wings (sorry, I've no idea what it's called) is worth, so I need some opinions from you guys.
View the trade here

1) They are overpaying.

2) Not even demand could make that fair. Thats quite unfair to you.

[Got That Jazz?]

Ok, I'm going to ask one more thing about my lion now, I already got the reply that [ this ] is unfair to me (I'm guessing demand-wise?). And apparently the lion is one of the dreamies that this person has (and the spider is one of my dreamies), so it would be nice to be able to work something out with them... So the question is, exactly how unfair is the trade?

And then a person gave me an offer on my mint horse. Surely there's a lot of pets on their side that I'm not interested in (like the horses, guinea pig, blue fox(?) and the lions), but still... I've no idea what the Shima dog and the black dog with wings (sorry, I've no idea what it's called) is worth, so I need some opinions from you guys.
View the trade here

The trade for your UR mint is extremely unfair too you, The group they offered would probably go for a mid-September, not an above the gap main list. Even though the demand for the Shima and Raven dog have insane demand, they definitely aren't worth that much. A FAIR trade that goes by the list for this would be like a high advent or bottom tier September.

[typewriter,]

c:
fair? c:

[Yirumaa]

c:
fair? c:

VERY unfair to you.

[Yirumaa]

I'm unsure, I really am bad at this rarity thing x_x
Anyways, could anyone give me their opinion on this? It looks..good..but, I repeat, I must make sure.

Here it is

fair

[typewriter,]

c:
fair? c:

VERY unfair to you.

Thank you
By how much?
Second opinion please? c:

[cowco34]

I'm unsure, I really am bad at this rarity thing x_x
Anyways, could anyone give me their opinion on this? It looks..good..but, I repeat, I must make sure.

Here it is

fair

Thanks!

[Yirumaa]

look at he's year...

[Summer~Breeze]

c:
fair? c:

VERY unfair to you.

Thank you
By how much?
Second opinion please? c:

Agreed, its worth around 7 09 rares, so you'd have to make your offer equal to that c:

[vegan smoothie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 16uIObmk8g
Fair? Thanks ^^