The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Minimetoo]

Them:

Me:

I think that it's a little unfair for me.. What can be removed or added?

[BrightPink]

Set of liontail dogs + red cerberus
for
black advent?

[Mana]

Blue balloon for Yellow Sorbet

[SagittariusII]

skele pps + vr pink shima bwolf + white dragon + red dragon + Halloween skele bun + purple ur horse + wood angel + 4 vr easter bunnies
for
green sorbet?
I know that's a lot of pets, but is it fair?

[Spectreselva]

Not sure yet if I'll accept it, but, and I'm using the official list of names for the dogs...:

Rare Blue/Aqua Light Stripe
Rare Blue/Aqua Spotted October
Rare Royal Bobtail
Rare Floppy Border Collie
Rare Blue Swirl Advent
Rare Purple Husky/Heart
Rare December brown and tan rat
Rare Blue Field/Grass Dog
Rare Purple rat
Rare Grey parrot rat
Rare Lemon-spotted Dalmation
Rare Blue parrot rat
Rare White St. Patrick's day rat x2
Rare 2nd Gen valentines rat
Rare Malk Valentine '09 PPS
Rare Heart Valentine PPS
Rare Green April Fools cat
Uncommon Nick Green toxic
Rare Purple grinner
Very Rare April brown stripe rat
Very rare Black and white 09 bunny
Rare pink 09 dog tag bunny
Rare Pink stripe/spot rat
Rare Green stripe/spot rat
Rare June rat(dunno what to call the thing)
Rare Dark Wood Dog
Rare Spider web bunny
Rare Boar GUPPS
Rare Purple-star Bobtail
Rare white tiger stripe rat
Rare Blue Seal PPS
Rare Brown Seal PPS
Rare May lion

For:

VR Rainbow Mane
VR Patchy Pink september

They want me to edit, I'm the RBM, and september. So, what's fair, are any of these even fair to the RBM? Or the september?

Any other opinions on this?

[Minimetoo]

Blue balloon for Yellow Sorbet

Unfair to Yellow sorbet, I believe.

[supercrown]

agreed ^^
at least i think soo, but i am pretty sure unfait to sorbet

[BrightPink]

Blue balloon for Yellow Sorbet

Unfair to Yellow sorbet, I believe.

agreed, viewtopic.php?f=20&t=112366

[Max Caulfield]

for

(all wishlist pets)

I don't know if this is fair... I was thinking unfair to the android. If its unfair what should I add/remove?

[supercrown]

Unfair to Android, there not worth just a bunch of uncommons >_<
maybe i think just put two 09 rares or somewhere by those lines? im not sure on exactly what to add, but it is unfair to the android