The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Kitsune Eika]

Okay, what I don't think this person is getting is that they're asking for two '09 uncommons, which are of more value(?) than '10 commons, right?


for

[Benvolio Montague]

Someone sent me this trade and I don't think it's fair, but I'm never really sure about the value of items so I'm checking it here:

their side: '09 uncommon dog and '09 uncommon rat
my side: these pets, including all the items: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=15096738 http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=12172587

Depends which uncommon dog/rat.

these ones: http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=4084006
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/viewpet.php?id=4634042

[Rosalind]

@Kitsune Eika-Yes they are, I don't think that is fair to you.

They offer

(Rat is for hoard.)
They want


They offer

They want

[Lighty]

Okay, what I don't think this person is getting is that they're asking for two '09 uncommons, which are of more value(?) than '10 commons, right?


for

I think that might be unfair to the other person but it's pretty close to fair

[KiwiKoala]

Okay, what I don't think this person is getting is that they're asking for two '09 uncommons, which are of more value(?) than '10 commons, right?


for

I think that might be unfair to the other person but it's pretty close to fair

Not fair to you.

[answrs]

@Kitsune Eika-Yes they are, I don't think that is fair to you.

They offer

(Rat is for hoard.)
They want


They offer

They want

1st = Unfair to leopard dog

[DisabledLlama]

for

[SMR]

I'm not sure about this trade. :\

They offer:

and


for:


Pet's name: Nilla (Vanilla)
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!


Pet's name: Beagle
Adopt virtual pets at Chicken Smoothie!

I think it's slightly unfair to them but I'm not sure. :\

[dozy]

DisabledLlama: Unfair to BE Galaxy
Rosalind: 1 is unfair to the Jan dog.
2 is unfair to the side with most dogs.
smr11415: Unfair to you ^-^

[Max Caulfield]

They offer -

They want -