The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Kaliyana]

for...

To me, that looks extremely unfair to the bottom group...
2 Rare Horses, and 8 Uncommons for 6 Uncommon Cats??
Nope nope, doesn't seem fair to me... Not at all...

Heh. And here I was thinking I might be under offering for the cats ^^; Warrior Cat rarities confuse me....If I took out the two rare horses, would that be fair-ish? I don't mind it being a bit unfair to me. ;d (I'm on bottom, btw)

I'm not 100% sure what would make it fair if you took out the Rare Horses (those where what made it seem unfair to me in the first place. )
6 Uncommons for 6 Uncommons is usually what I do (I try to make them as close in adoption date as possible) ... Warrior Cat rarities confuse me too, so I'd say offer 6 Uncommons + maybe 1 or 2 more Uncommon, just to make it more appealing to them if you really want the cats.

[Shian]

Actually the trade with the cats looks fine to me. The old Warriors are highly sought after and that valentine cat is pretty rare. Not many people are looking for the pets on the other side, so it balances itself out.

[Bakura]

green malk drag + candycane store drag + rudolph + green & black sotre dog

for
09 halloween ghost cat

[starshooter102]

for



If this isn't fair what can I get for the boar?

[Kenjja]

Two yellow (This months) store pets
-for-
Blue Rose & Red Rose

[Diabolic]

Two yellow (This months) store pets
-for-
Blue Rose & Red Rose

Way unfair for the rose dogs.

[RarityClarity]

08 November bobtail and Mustard Heart 08 advent for both 08 christmas cats and the 08 advent angel dog.

------------------------

Also, 08 Red Rose, Target Dog, Yin Yang Green October, 08 Red Heavy Stripe, Green-fronted Holly Dog, Fox Advent, ale Flower Advent, Pink Cookie Advent, 2009 Rare Owl PPS, Neutral Morality, Orange August 09 2nd gen, 6 uncommon horses, 2 rare horses, Black advent, 2 of the Brown Seal PPS store pets, Red Android, and 15 hoard pets (all uncommon) for my Joker.

------------------------

Also, rare 2010 green lion and rare blue parrot rat for the fox advent cat.

[Diabolic]

08 November bobtail and Mustard Heart 08 advent for both 08 christmas cats and the 08 advent angel dog.

------------------------

Also, 08 Red Rose, Target Dog, Yin Yang Green October, 08 Red Heavy Stripe, Green-fronted Holly Dog, Fox Advent, ale Flower Advent, Pink Cookie Advent, 2009 Rare Owl PPS, Neutral Morality, Orange August 09 2nd gen, 6 uncommon horses, 2 rare horses, Black advent, 2 of the Brown Seal PPS store pets, Red Android, and 15 hoard pets (all uncommon) for my Joker.

------------------------

Also, rare 2010 green lion and rare blue parrot rat for the fox advent cat.

First one is very unfair for the angel advent side.

Second one is unfair for the Joker.

Third one might be fair. It depends on how one values the lion. Some think it is worth a 08 advent, others don't.

[Candied Snow]

for
card dogs K♦ and Q ♣

[Kitsune Eika]