Equine Transformation Project - VOTING CLOSED

[nickjr]

[snip]

I'm not certain if nickjr is discussing the same issues, but there is VERY strong evidence that Equimagine copied some of her horses directly from photographs.

Wait what? I only said that equimagine was retired and that last time I checked we couldn't use her linearts since she's retired xD;

And the evidence pointed only to the first set of linearts (plus a unicorn); people were asking what was wrong with the second set (which was made in response to the evidence against the first set)

That's why I said I wasn't sure if you were discussing the same thing as I was thinking.

Whoops, my apologies; I skipped over that part -hides-

[akebai]

Here's a link to the suspected traced images and a comparison of the line-art to them.
http://ravenpop.tumblr.com/post/45639322186

[asexual]

I am really hoping the rainbow maned horse gets put in the new lines, I'd value it much higher then, simply because the lines would be 100% true.

In all honesty guys we should be looking at this in a manner that asks: "What's good for CS as a site?" not "What would make ME happy?"

[Ljubica]

I don't want them to be changed cuz i think its cool having lots of different line-arts.

[Harpy•]

I am really hoping the rainbow maned horse gets put in the new lines, I'd value it much higher then, simply because the lines would be 100% true.

In all honesty guys we should be looking at this in a manner that asks: "What's good for CS as a site?" not "What would make ME happy?"

Exactly. I feel as if the arguments against the change, no offense meant to anyone who argues against it, are more self-centered, describing their love for the look and how much they'd miss the lineart, etc. I haven't seen much, if anything, argument-wise that focuses on the good of the CS website as a WHOLE.

[Taiger Lilly]

Click the link~

That's the 'issues' people are talking about~ some people think that they were traced. (Which, two look like they are imo, buuut, everyone has different opinions~)

I was asking about the Second set of lines she made, because I thought they were fine, but another user said they had "issues" too (I've assumed they meant tracing etc.) and I asked for proof of that.

[Harpalyce]

In all honesty guys we should be looking at this in a manner that asks: "What's good for CS as a site?" not "What would make ME happy?"

Well-stated.

Keep in mind as well that Equimagine herself admitted there were some issues with the lineart. I do not think it was intentional, I do not want to start a witch-hunt against her. She has settled that with Tess to where both of them are satisfied. But the fact remains that some dubious lineart is still in use. I think things would be much better for everyone if we switched to lineart we know to be "kosher".

[tacocat.]

I am really hoping the rainbow maned horse gets put in the new lines, I'd value it much higher then, simply because the lines would be 100% true.

In all honesty guys we should be looking at this in a manner that asks: "What's good for CS as a site?" not "What would make ME happy?"

Exactly. I feel as if the arguments against the change, no offense meant to anyone who argues against it, are more self-centered, describing their love for the look and how much they'd miss the lineart, etc. I haven't seen much, if anything, argument-wise that focuses on the good of the CS website as a WHOLE.

And anyways, no one gave a crap about the old lineart before this new idea was preposed. And all of a sudden equid's lineart horses are everyone's favorite.

[Silverwulfess]

I LOVE this idea. I LOVE the more recent line art but wasn't too keen on the previous. This is the best of both worlds!

[Harpy•]

I am really hoping the rainbow maned horse gets put in the new lines, I'd value it much higher then, simply because the lines would be 100% true.

In all honesty guys we should be looking at this in a manner that asks: "What's good for CS as a site?" not "What would make ME happy?"

Exactly. I feel as if the arguments against the change, no offense meant to anyone who argues against it, are more self-centered, describing their love for the look and how much they'd miss the lineart, etc. I haven't seen much, if anything, argument-wise that focuses on the good of the CS website as a WHOLE.

And anyways, no one gave a crap about the old lineart before this new idea was preposed. And all of a sudden equid's lineart horses are everyone's favorite. :roll:

ALSO a fantastic point.