The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 457]

[Patch.]

This?

The guniea pig is from '08 I believe. :c

It's actually from 2010, and I believe it's unfair to you.
But I'm not the best with items, so I'd get another opinion. ^^

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24900783

Fair? That was also a gifted dreamie but Im not sure

Wrong link. ^^
Please use the "share link".

[answrs]

I'd really appreciate some input on a couple of trades. Thank you for any advice given. ^-^

Pet trades:
#1 - Pretty sure it's good, but the aussie seems to be pretty popular lately, so idk.
#2 - I have zero idea how much the tree dog's worth has settled around, but the stores I know are around a late 10/early 11 rare.

Item trades: (notes are based on Items Guide thread)
#3 - full pumpkin set is apparently a mid 09 rare, balloon is mid 10 unc, not sure what half a set would be.
#4 - wings are an Oct/Nov 08 each, flower bracelet is mid 09 rare (pretty sure it's unfair to me, but confirmation would be nice)
#5 - based on items guide, the items are worth 2 Nov 08 rares + 1 early 09 rare + 2 mid 09 rares + 6 late 09 rares

Please, anyone?

[cacticollie]

This?

The guniea pig is from '08 I believe. :c

It's actually from 2010, and I believe it's unfair to you.
But I'm not the best with items, so I'd get another opinion. ^^

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24900783

Fair? That was also a gifted dreamie but Im not sure

Wrong link. ^^
Please use the "share link".

I thought '10
My brain typed '08
D:< Brain! Thanks Tiger! Second opinon then, please? o u o

[Snowytoshi]

I'd really appreciate some input on a couple of trades. Thank you for any advice given. ^-^

Pet trades:
#1 - Pretty sure it's good, but the aussie seems to be pretty popular lately, so idk.
#2 - I have zero idea how much the tree dog's worth has settled around, but the stores I know are around a late 10/early 11 rare.

Item trades: (notes are based on Items Guide thread)
#3 - full pumpkin set is apparently a mid 09 rare, balloon is mid 10 unc, not sure what half a set would be.
#4 - wings are an Oct/Nov 08 each, flower bracelet is mid 09 rare (pretty sure it's unfair to me, but confirmation would be nice)
#5 - based on items guide, the items are worth 2 Nov 08 rares + 1 early 09 rare + 2 mid 09 rares + 6 late 09 rares

Please, anyone?

Both pet trades are unfair to them...

[Patch.]

I'd really appreciate some input on a couple of trades. Thank you for any advice given. ^-^

Pet trades:
#1 - Pretty sure it's good, but the aussie seems to be pretty popular lately, so idk.
#2 - I have zero idea how much the tree dog's worth has settled around, but the stores I know are around a late 10/early 11 rare.

Item trades: (notes are based on Items Guide thread)
#3 - full pumpkin set is apparently a mid 09 rare, balloon is mid 10 unc, not sure what half a set would be.
#4 - wings are an Oct/Nov 08 each, flower bracelet is mid 09 rare (pretty sure it's unfair to me, but confirmation would be nice)
#5 - based on items guide, the items are worth 2 Nov 08 rares + 1 early 09 rare + 2 mid 09 rares + 6 late 09 rares

Please, anyone?

1) Unfair to them. The two rare dogs are actually a fair swap because of the 3-month rule, but that's up to you.
2) I say unfair to them because their store dog is worth a late 2010 rare to an early 2011 rare.
3) - 5) I'm not very good with items, sorry. :c

[aortic]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... bf5O_5QAfA
If not, what should be added?

[Taito]

:3 Hey! Would someone mind telling me how this trade is demand-wise? - http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... XF84fMfrGw I'm tempted because of the '09 UR and the cucumber alone being overpay, but with the cucumber's bad demand I'm not sure...

I would do the trade because of the cucumber and '09 UR dog. The cucumber itself would be overpaying because it's an entire tier above the coontail.

Thank you! May I have an opinion on demand though please? :3

Thank you again for the other reply on rarity fairness, but demand-wise? ^^'

[Raviolli]

Is this fair?

[ThatCoffeeBoi]

Could someone give me an estimate on how many more of the eggs from this month it would take to equal the rares in this trade? c:
I know it will probably be a lot, so I apologize for asking a difficult question. But any answers are appreciated!


ALSO. What might fill the gap between the 08 UR cat and the UR lion? c:

[nope.]

2011 Store Pet + Voodoo Cat from 2010 + ??? = Malk Mutant