The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Solidagold]

Thank you ^^

if maybe swapping that dog for a 09 VR rat, would that make any difference?

Okay, so Someone answered this for me earlier, but can I have some other opinions before I accept?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... by4BbN4KoA

Unfair to you.
Your dog is a 2008 VR and their PPS is a 2010 VR.

[Snowytoshi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Q296jMAUnw

Was this fair?

[Pi.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... qLm0rUhlow
Fair?

[Patch.]

How does this trade look?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lT4ZXKTfbg
Experienced answers only, please.

I would say you are over paying. : ) 2 groupS above the red holly goes for 10 09 rares so i was told so i doubt it is that much
EDIT: I ment the group with Purple bob tail and ect. goes for 10 09 rares x.x

Thank you for answering. c:
Can you please tell me what needs to be removed.

I am not sure, but i think taking out the 08 VR should even it out. If i am counting correctly that is. A mid advent is about 7mid 09 rares, that should give you some ground to work on : )

Um...I don't have a 2008 VR in there. xD
Do you mean the 2008 rare or the 2009 VR?

[candu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24265382&userid=366427&signature=Jh1qLUnHAnVrqLm0rUhlow
Fair?

I think the Malk Cat is overpaying. Malk is super popular now that she's retired, plus it's from 2010.

[candu]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24265382&userid=366427&signature=Jh1qLUnHAnVrqLm0rUhlow
Fair?

I think the Malk Cat is overpaying. Malk is super popular now that she's retired, plus it's from 2010.

[CarrieJo..♥]

Hello~ I was wondering which of these bids would be more fair, or if any of them would be considered as such since I am looking for a winner and I honestly have no idea.

#1 Someone told me that this would be closer to fair than some, but the only toxic I was looking for was the green one or the full set. Which seems rather outrageous on the full set to me..
#2 I know that the July PPS is under the UR cat in the rares list by two spaces, but the rabbit with the spider web was kinda cute to me.

Thank you ahead of time for taking the time to help me out. And thank you Tiger, tiger for helping me narrow it down.

[Snowytoshi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24262618&userid=398636&signature=RPP3xoD-IKyRQ296jMAUnw

Was this fair?

[Kyar]

How does this trade look?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lT4ZXKTfbg
Experienced answers only, please.

I would say you are over paying. : ) 2 groupS above the red holly goes for 10 09 rares so i was told so i doubt it is that much
EDIT: I ment the group with Purple bob tail and ect. goes for 10 09 rares x.x

Thank you for answering. c:
Can you please tell me what needs to be removed.

I am not sure, but i think taking out the 08 VR should even it out. If i am counting correctly that is. A mid advent is about 7mid 09 rares, that should give you some ground to work on : )

I disagree a bit. Mids go for 9 09 rares so I'd say it's pretty much good right now especially since the holly is low demand. :)

[Patch.]

How does this trade look?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lT4ZXKTfbg
Experienced answers only, please.

I would say you are over paying. : ) 2 groupS above the red holly goes for 10 09 rares so i was told so i doubt it is that much
EDIT: I ment the group with Purple bob tail and ect. goes for 10 09 rares x.x

Thank you for answering. c:
Can you please tell me what needs to be removed.

I am not sure, but i think taking out the 08 VR should even it out. If i am counting correctly that is. A mid advent is about 7mid 09 rares, that should give you some ground to work on : )

Um...I don't have a 2008 VR in there. xD
Do you mean the 2008 rare or the 2009 VR?