The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Fat Unicorn]

Would trading a red Cerberus for this cat be an up-trade? Please and thank you! ♥


Technically yes, but ceberus demand is high, so I wouldn't take it.


Okay, thank you! I'd still like some more opinions. I'm really trying to get up to a CE Galaxy and this is what I have to start with.

Agreed. ^^

Are these fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... F7dhqIcuEA

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ijVVSYiFlQ

A second opinion please and what should be added to make the top one fair

1. A late 09 rare rat
2. looks about fair, I think yours is a 08 re-release, so maby add an uncommon to their side.

I disagree.
1. Unfair to you, they should add a early 2009 rare rat.
2. Looked fair to me, and yes, your dog is a 2008 rerelease. :3

[e-sheep]

Is this fair?

[♥Sterek♥]

Is this fair?

I would say unfair to you/

[e-sheep]

Is this fair?

I would say unfair to you/

Thanks.

Would it be fair, if I removed the uncommon on my side? Or would I have to remove something on their side as well?

[~Promise]

Is this fair?

[Fat Unicorn]

Is this fair?

I would say unfair to you/

Please don't give incorrect advice. ^^
Unfair to them, the armor on their side is from July 2011, and the Yellow Hibiscus comes from the Beach Event, which crosses out the Orange one. The items on e-sheep's side are from the Beach Event, and are less valuable - combined - with the other person's items. And the pets on their side is overpay (Black Dragon dog is from July 2011, instant overpay on both pets on e-sheep's side). :3

Is this fair?

It was unfair to them technically.

[SnowFlakeSwan]

Is this fair?

[~Promise]

Is this fair?

It was unfair to them technically.

Thank you What do you mean by technically? Are you talking demand...?

[Lively..]

Is this fair? Rarity and demand wise please :3 Thanks
And
Which has better demand? Dogtag or UR Bwolf? { Which would be easier to trade off? }

Better demand? Dogtag! Awesome thingummy... ^^

Second opinion please?

[Fat Unicorn]

Is this fair?

It was unfair to them technically.

Thank you What do you mean by technically? Are you talking demand...?

No. :3 Technically means in terms of actual rarity, none or almost no demand involved.

Is this fair?

Unfair to them.

Is this fair? Rarity and demand wise please :3 Thanks
And
Which has better demand? Dogtag or UR Bwolf?

Better demand? Dogtag! Awesome thingummy... ^^

Second opinion please?

Unfair to them technically, and the Dogtag has more demand. ^^