The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[octoberwind]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24181719&userid=236313&signature=KNybo_S9ZVpSqFawm4vTHg
Is this fair? thanks!

[Morticia]

What would these two pets:

(both Valentines 09 Very Rares)
Need to add to be fair for a Blue Snowflake Scarf Dog?
Also, what would they need to add to be fair for a Zombie Pony?

Its already overpay for the scarf dog (he is worth 2 09 early rares)
And for the zombie pony (which is worth 2 09 early rares and some 09 uncommons)

Oh ok, thank you ^^
Would one of them be fair for the Zombie Pony?
Sorry for all the questions, I'm just really bad at trading onto the Advent List

No, it wouldn't be fair if it was just one for a zombie pony. c:

Ok, thank you c: Then what one one of them need to add for the pony? Since I've been told that both is unfair to me, and one is unfair to them xD

[snil]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z1iJI_NMRA
is this fair? thanks in advance

[e-sheep]

Is this

That's unfair to you.

Thank you. How much is the horse or the dog worth, if they're alone?
And what do I have to remove here to make it fair?

[Fat Unicorn]

@ Queen of Anything: About 1 2009 Rare + 1 2009 UC. :3

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... z1iJI_NMRA
is this fair? thanks in advance

Unfair to them. ^^

Is this

That's unfair to you.

Thank you. How much is the horse or the dog worth, if they're alone?
And what do I have to remove here to make it fair?

Wolf, please don't give incorrect advice - that was unfair to them. e-sheep, the horse/dog on your side are worth another 2012 rare. ^^

[Birdy]

Fair to a Blue Rose?
If not, what should be added?

[Delete/this/account]

{ Hello! Just wondering is this fair? Thank you!

Here it is. Thank you for help!

[♥Sterek♥]

{ Hello! Just wondering is this fair? Thank you!

Here it is. Thank you for help!

Please use the share trade button ^^


@Teddyrosa, thats unfair to the bleu rose

[Birdy]

@Teddyrosa, thats unfair to the bleu rose

Thank you! Do you have any idea of what could be added to their side to make it fair? :3

[Planet Karma]

This is extremely unfair to my items, so what should they add?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... nhiEb1DvCg