The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [rule about quoting!]

[Nightingale's Eyes]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Er3TlatLLA

Demand wise fair?

[Kuzco]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24183168&userid=1984&signature=_qZ4-VhsGChWp7skHNT-hA
What do I need to add in order to make this fair?
Thanks to those who help - I'm dreadful at main list.

Not really sure, but maybe a Rare's list or September list that is not more valuable as the dog on the top.

I'm sorry, what? "Rares list" is pretty vague, and applies to main list, advents, and septembers.
Can someone else give me an estimate?

[Godiva]

Me and my trading partner are trying to figure out if this is fair?
Thank you for any help! ^^

[Morticia]

Are these fair? (:
One
Two
Three

first 2 look unfair to you

Ok, thank you c:
Can I get a second opinion on those, and an opinion on the third one please?

[historyOtaku]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24183367&userid=339037&signature=XDT9fp9OodgO0Jtr9meRpQ

Would this be fair? Thank you in advance. c:

[Ghoul (gone)]

Is this fair?
If it's unfair to me, what should I replace the cat with? If it's unfair to them, what should I take from their side? Thanks! ^u^

Not exactly sure, and you shou get a second opinion, but I think it's unfair to you. That cat is worth a tommorw than all of those items, I believe.
As I said before, get a second opinion.

I agree, most of the items are free items and the few store items aren;t even the whole set.

Okay, what should I change my side to? 2009 uncommon, 2010 rare, 2010 uncommon..? Thanks ^u^

[Ginger Fox]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FwLzkaHsrg
what should I change with this, if anything?
Should I change the draft for a rare 2010 rat?

[Rakkun]

is this fair?

[white . horse]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24183168&userid=1984&signature=_qZ4-VhsGChWp7skHNT-hA
What do I need to add in order to make this fair?
Thanks to those who help - I'm dreadful at main list.

Not really sure, but maybe a Rare's list or September list that is not more valuable as the dog on the top.

I'm sorry, what? "Rares list" is pretty vague, and applies to main list, advents, and septembers.
Can someone else give me an estimate?

sorry, I meant Main List and September list. Sorry to upset you.

[honee bee]

Double checking, lion for butterfly wolf?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zCIYl43l2w