The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[lucifer morningstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24174916&userid=399238&signature=W316zdrbb0XoRtPsCWZYYQ

Please help me? I think it's unfair to me, but it's for an auction. What could they add (if it was a normal trade)?
I'm new, and really bad with rarities. Cx

Thanks! <3

Unfair to you. I'm not entirely sure on what could be added though.

[Silverwulfess]

Is this fair? Thanks

I'd say unfair for them ^^

Thanks, could I please get another opinion?

[Kyar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24174916&userid=399238&signature=W316zdrbb0XoRtPsCWZYYQ

Please help me? I think it's unfair to me, but it's for an auction. What could they add (if it was a normal trade)?
I'm new, and really bad with rarities. Cx

Thanks! <3

Unfair to you. I'm not entirely sure on what could be added though.

The shima is only worth an early 09 rare and since you've got an early 09 VR on your side I'd say they should add about another early 09 rare. :) In an auction setting you'll need to change your bid according to the other bidders of course but right now that's where it's at as far as fairness goes in a trade setting. :)

Is this fair? Thanks

I'd say unfair for them ^^

Thanks, could I please get another opinion?

Agreed. :)

[zee99]

Is this fair? Thanks

I'd say unfair for them ^^

Thanks, could I please get another opinion?

Agreed, unfair to them.

[Colorado]

Is this fair? Thanks

I'd say unfair for them ^^

Thanks, could I please get another opinion?

Unfair to them

[Kevinsaurus]

---

[Fantelle]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24174916&userid=399238&signature=W316zdrbb0XoRtPsCWZYYQ

Please help me? I think it's unfair to me, but it's for an auction. What could they add (if it was a normal trade)?
I'm new, and really bad with rarities. Cx

Thanks! <3

The dog you offered is from 08 i think or 09' i forget.The shima Longtail is kinda of a demand i guess.But i'm just gonna say..a little unfair to you..first the Shima Longtail is a rare and yours is a very fair..you might want ask someone else opinion 'cause mine probaly sucks..

thank you and thank you to stonestable and kyar too! The dog is from january 2009, and you're probably right. I really want the longtail, but I probably have something lesser to offer. Thanks!

[Dakotak]

I know the Wolf PPS is low on the main list and the Red Cerberus is equal to that of a September list and the Blue rose is on the September list. So this would be a over pay on the Wolf PPS correct?


For

Mm... no I'd say that's pretty close. It looks about right to me but maybe slightly unfair to the PPS. Only by a few 09 rares though is all.

With demand it is very close.

Thank you guys. <3
Would adding this Koi help bridge the gap some more?

[Kevinsaurus]

New thread, no marking/spam please http://www.chickensmoothie.com/Forum/viewtopic.php?f=20&p=50028656#p50028656

[Piera]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... u0bDSKGqIw
ive edited back and forth but im still not sure,so is it unfair to them? If so ,how could i make it fair?