The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[♥Sterek♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24158212&userid=372960&signature=Ckf5SapePzZiTJeSwfoyag Fair?

Unfair to them, and please dont post twice

[_Cat~Eye_]

Is this Trade fair if not What could be add
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lcQ1Zju6dw

[abel.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Qy1umoAQrA

Fair? Please and thank you.

[DarkGaia]

Is this trade fair? :3 Thanks for your help!

[♥Sterek♥]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24158463&userid=123144&signature=NcT2TzO1n5s4Qy1umoAQrA

Fair? Please and thank you.

very unfair to you. remove the pink sorbet from your side and it is fair rarity wise.

[My Chemical Reaction]

This is unfair...right? I'm not sure.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ItVNPpC-EA

[Namine]

is this fair or no good?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gf2KXpwADw

[~illbewaiting]

This is unfair...right? I'm not sure.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ItVNPpC-EA

Yes. It's very unfair to you.

[♥Sterek♥]

is this fair or no good?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... gf2KXpwADw

Looks a little unfair to them

This is unfair...right? I'm not sure.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ItVNPpC-EA

very unfair to you

[dunsparce]

I'm looking to trade a complete set of 08 items consisting of 1 reindeer, 3 pocky, 1 halo, 2 white scarves, 2 green scarves, 3 merry christmas', 3 white socks, 3 green socks, and 4 santa hats for a Blue Rose.

I went to the item worth thread first, so I could get a rough estimate, but the person who did pointed me here, since I'm looking to get a low list pet for them all and it's a question of fair trading, roundabouts. c:

Together it's:
4x Oct/Nov '08 rare or multiple '09 rares
Low September '08 list pet
10x Late '09 rare
4x Mid '09 rare
3x Mid '09 uncommon

Grinner is worth around 13 mid-late '09 rares, so:
4x Oct/Nov '08 rare or multiple '09 rares
Low September '08 list pet
1 Grinner
1 mid '09 rare
3x mid '09 uncommon

Let's say multiple '09 rares means 3-4 early '09 rares, then it'd be around 12-16 early '09 rares and we'd have another grinner, so:
2 Grinner
Low September '08 list pet
1 mid '09 rare
3x mid '09 uncommon

Now we have low September list pet + mid '09 rare + 3x mid '09 uncommon = fetched grinner.
3x Grinner = 1 Blue Rose.

So Blue Rose, but you can ask someone who knows CS Math better to make sure. (:

tl;dr- So, the question is if a Blue Rose would be a fair trade for them all?