The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[elder price]

what needs to be added to their side to make this fair? I don't mind overpaying a little, and a fast answer is always appreciated! thank you in advance! C: <3

[MaySkyward]

3 pets for 5 store items

I'm not really one who can tell if trades are fair between items and pets, so any help is appreciated. <3
In my opinion it isn't fair, but I would like to make sure. c:

[lana del rey]

3 pets for 5 store items

I'm not really one who can tell if trades are fair between items and pets, so any help is appreciated. <3
In my opinion it isn't fair, but I would like to make sure. c:

not fair to the items. c:

[KioloDovahkiin]

Would this be fair?

I don't know about demand or anything so I'm not sure about the trade.

Thanks,
~ Leroy

[Law]

Would this be fair?

I don't know about demand or anything so I'm not sure about the trade.

Thanks,
~ Leroy

Unfair to you

[November.Fox]

Rarity wise, it is unfair to you. Demand wise, unfair to them. Honestly, it depends on the person you're sending it to if it'll get accepted or not.

Ouch. My brain is hurting now lol. So technically... If you balance the two unfair parts... It's equal by my thoughts lol

I think what they're saying is its unfair to me because the lion has lots of demand (:

Actually, I'm saying it's all up to the owner of the lion. With a pet like that, it's very difficult to say what's fair and what's not. If the owner of the lion likes the trade, then it must be fair in their eyes. But if they don't, they're relying more on demand then rarity. So it's up to them, in the end.

Yes, if the lion didn't have insane amounts of demand and most people didn't want insane overpay, it would be a heck of a lot easier to say, but since it does and since with that particular pet, it's really up to the two that are trading. I'm not going to pick sides and say it's fair or unfair to either of them, because it honestly is unfair to both of them in two different ways. In my eyes, anyway. Please, correct me if I'm wrong, anyone.

Speaking honestly, you probably could get a lot more for the lion since way too many people are willing to overpay, but that's not to say the trade they sent isn't already overpaying, because they are. The person offering the pets for the lion is overpaying rarity wise, but you most likely can find people who are willing to offer more, interestingly enough.

[Tea.Time]

for

Unfair to the Olive Green Field or the Pointy Field/Grass dog? Or Equal trade?

thanks in advance ^ ^

[Law]

for

Unfair to the Olive Green Field or the Pointy Field/Grass dog? Or Equal trade?

thanks in advance ^ ^

They should be. They even turned rare in the same month.

[November.Fox]

Fair?

Demand wise also?

Unfair to you.

Thanks! Second opinions, anyone? ^^;

[bnom]

Is it good demand-wise? What has better demand?
Thanks!