The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[Centri]

Timberwolf PPS for Angel advent?

[huskynerd]

them
me

and is this fair?

for

Hmm...well, the Boar unPPS turned rare not too long ago. The bunny might be fair since it used to be uncommon (and it's not a dog) but it is significantly older, so I'm not sure. The second one is unfair to the Blood dog.

[Seasonal]

uhm....I'm just.....dumbfounded, so...er... help? lol

*image removed to save space*

for


PLUS the other three PPS from this month

Maybe a bit unfair to you?

Honestly, I think that it is alright; unfair to the other side, at least. Only two of the dogs on the larger side are '08 Dogs, and they're Uncommon. The others are either "common" Rares or rarer Uncommons, while the other side has an October '08 Rat and an Advent '08 Rat, along with the May Lion and the two Store PPS pets.

[versicolor]

Would this be fair?
Them:
Light Aqua Stripe from October 08
Common Robot Dog from January 09
Black-spotted Dalmatian from February 09
Liver-spotted Dalmatian from February 09
Red Fireworks Dog from March 09
Mismatch Aztec from March 09
Pointy Zombie from March 09
Green Dart Frog BW from May 09
Red Dart Frog BW from May 09
Wildebeest BW from July 09
Bongo BW from July 09
Panda GUPPS from Advent Calendar 09
Bay Appaloosa from January '10
Pink Valentine '10 Wolf
Two Rare Bunnies from '10
The Guinea Pig from Easter '10
Yellow & Black striped 2nd gen BW from this month

Me: Dark Pink Shima BW

I have a feeling it's unfair to them, but I'm not entirely sure ^^;

[Endiriana]

are these 2 trades fair:

them:
me:


them: 2X
me:

[BlossomTail]

are these 2 trades fair:

them:
me:


them: 2X
me:

Both of them are unfair to you.
I would suggest them pick 'lower-class' pets, as in 2009 for the first.
For the second, I'd add in a couple of '09 pets to their side ^-^

[~Demonic~]

for

I know it is unfair, but what do you suggest I add?

[Endiriana]

them: 2X
me:

Both of them are unfair to you.
I would suggest them pick 'lower-class' pets, as in 2009 for the first.
For the second, I'd add in a couple of '09 pets to their side ^-^

and what about 4 of the cake dogs? (I'm hoarding them^^)

[Diabolic]

Would this be fair?
Them:
Light Aqua Stripe from October 08
Common Robot Dog from January 09
Black-spotted Dalmatian from February 09
Liver-spotted Dalmatian from February 09
Red Fireworks Dog from March 09
Mismatch Aztec from March 09
Pointy Zombie from March 09
Green Dart Frog BW from May 09
Red Dart Frog BW from May 09
Wildebeest BW from July 09
Bongo BW from July 09
Panda GUPPS from Advent Calendar 09
Bay Appaloosa from January '10
Pink Valentine '10 Wolf
Two Rare Bunnies from '10
The Guinea Pig from Easter '10
Yellow & Black striped 2nd gen BW from this month

Me: Dark Pink Shima BW

I have a feeling it's unfair to them, but I'm not entirely sure ^^;

Actually, that is unfair for the Shima BW.

[AnnaKitten]

Question:
Woodangel for:
UC '08 Blue Stripe Dog, Rare '09 Malk PPS Horse, UC '09 Arrow Rat, VR '09 Easter Pink Balloon Bunny,
R '09 Rose Rat, Rare Nick '09 Sun Horse, C '09 Blue Dog, Uc '09 Balloon Dog Black and White, R Royal
Bobtail, Uc '10 New Year PPS, R Drink Me Dog, R Dark Chocolate Easter '10 Dog, 2 VC '10 dogs (Every pet is
on the players WL)[/quote]