The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[KioloDovahkiin]

is this even fair?

and

would I be likely to trade the rat off at all?

I am curious about these trades. The second I know is fair, but I know rats can be a pain to trade off.

It is very hard to trade off the rat. I

I'd say first trade is unfair towards you. They need to add a few rares to even it out. Also second trade also seems unfair, rats are hard to trade off, even if the cat is worth perhaps 2 dogs.

~ Leroy

[Ironic Equation]

is this even fair?

and

would I be likely to trade the rat off at all?

I am curious about these trades. The second I know is fair, but I know rats can be a pain to trade off.

It is very hard to trade off the rat. I

I'd say first trade is unfair towards you. They need to add a few rares to even it out. Also second trade also seems unfair, rats are hard to trade off, even if the cat is worth perhaps 2 dogs.

~ Leroy

There is a Wolf PPS in the first one and several advents. They are not worth an advent and some random rares+

[brad!]

Would a marionette and a patchwork be fair for a brown cookie?

[Kyar]

Would a marionette and a patchwork be fair for a brown cookie?

Unfair to the marionette and patchwork. :)

[brad!]

Would a marionette and a patchwork be fair for a brown cookie?

Unfair to the marionette and patchwork.

Thanks, what would the cookie need to add?

[Kyar]

Would a marionette and a patchwork be fair for a brown cookie?

Unfair to the marionette and patchwork. :)

Thanks, what would the cookie need to add?

A couple 09 rares would do nicely. :)

[brad!]

Would a marionette and a patchwork be fair for a brown cookie?

Unfair to the marionette and patchwork.

Thanks, what would the cookie need to add?

A couple 09 rares would do nicely.

Alright, thank-you.

[ron]

Could I get another opinion on this one? I am still not sure. Is it fair? Or should I remove/add something?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23882793&userid=154694&signature=8QXiQRZC6LWgrA5OtIKsxg

Looks perfectly fair to me honestly.

Is the Wolf PPS actually worth that?

[sleepy3254]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23888085&userid=3499&signature=lSzL9AFXl1W3bCw8FNrrDg
Is that fair?

[Ironic Equation]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23888085&userid=3499&signature=lSzL9AFXl1W3bCw8FNrrDg
Is that fair?

Terribly unfair to you. Your rat is on the advent list.