The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[Kyar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23468684&userid=375990&signature=j2zUGEWtCehDkjg-0h2y_g

Is this fair? c:

Unfair to them. Theirs is an october 08 VR. :)

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AOd9sBRAmg
New borns are a Joker and a July PPS

Not neccarily. the newborn (first one) could be a card dog, and the other july litter could be a growing white july, OR a july pps. Thought i think its safe to say thats unfair to them. i believe, please do get a second opinion thought ^^;

They have to be those outcomes because if they were any of the others they would have grown already. :)

[Solidagold]

well it could be a joker, if the pup is too old to be another card dog?

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AOd9sBRAmg
New borns are a Joker and a July PPS

Not neccarily. the newborn (first one) could be a card dog, and the other july litter could be a growing white july, OR a july pps. Thought i think its safe to say thats unfair to them. i believe, please do get a second opinion thought ^^;

[Grace & Ria]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AOd9sBRAmg
New borns are a Joker and a July PPS

While I can't be sure about the new URs it seems unfair to them. As far as I'm aware the moonswirl is worth three nons and the July PPS alone is worth at least two.
The sorbet, galaxy pup, and toxic would equal the third non. I tend to place jokers around a non as well due to their demand. While the new UR cat seems to be far less valuable than the dog it is still around the mid/low main list from what I've seen and I would hesitantly put the new UR dog around the big gap level.

I agree, although Moonswirls value varies depending on personal opinion. ( Don't quote me on this, but I believe I was told by Fat Unicorn they value them around 4 nons, and I know I have traded two Moonswirls off with that value)

The UR Dog goes for about a non by the way, as does the Joker in some cases. So I'd say perhaps a little unfair to them.

[Fjäll Räven]

so, unfair to them? XD

[Kyar]

so, unfair to them? XD

I think between what State of Grace has said and what I have heard that is the general consensus. :)

[Solidagold]

Thank you ^-^ But should I accept? And (I know this is supposed to go on another thread) how much more could I get from the october 08' VR? I know Warriors are somewhat high in demand and I have never seen any trade threads asking specifically for one of those dogs?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23468684&userid=375990&signature=j2zUGEWtCehDkjg-0h2y_g

Is this fair? c:

Unfair to them. Theirs is an october 08 VR.

[Kyar]

Thank you ^-^ But should I accept? And (I know this is supposed to go on another thread) how much more could I get from the october 08' VR? I know Warriors are somewhat high in demand and I have never seen any trade threads asking specifically for one of those dogs? :?

I think you could get a lot more for an 08 VR than a warrior cat by rarity alone but I don't have a lot of experience trading with warrior cat fanatics. :) Personally I'd take the dog.

[Solidagold]

Even though it's a re-realease? Wow, okay. Thank you so much ^3^

Thank you ^-^ But should I accept? And (I know this is supposed to go on another thread) how much more could I get from the october 08' VR? I know Warriors are somewhat high in demand and I have never seen any trade threads asking specifically for one of those dogs?

I think you could get a lot more for an 08 VR than a warrior cat by rarity alone but I don't have a lot of experience trading with warrior cat fanatics. Personally I'd take the dog.

[♥Sterek♥]

Even though it's a re-realease?

rereleases are worth just as much as true date, only some people prefer true date.

Need some help on these 2:

This is a bid for the Ur lion, most of the pets are just uncommons and commons but the most valuable are these: target, drink me, ornament PPS, Seal PPS, red android, white lolita, GWJ

And this one is for the coontail.. is it fair?

[Foxtress]

Even though it's a re-realease?

rereleases are worth just as much as true date, only some people prefer true date.

Need some help on these 2:

This is a bid for the Ur lion, most of the pets are just uncommons and commons but the most valuable are these: target, drink me, ornament PPS, Seal PPS, red android, white lolita, GWJ

And this one is for the coontail.. is it fair?

1) -Missed GWJ- Ignore opinion please. xD

2) I don't know.