The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [FTT Contest!]

[lucifer morningstar]

Kyar, you are seriously the best. Thanks a million!

[Kyar]

Is this a fair trade for the DogTag? Please and thank you kindly!

I think it's safe to assume the pup is a nonswirl yeah? :) Well anyway it looks unfair to the dogtag in my opinion. The least I've ever heard of them going for is two nons and that doesn't add up to two nons unless I missed something big. :)

Edit:
No problem stonestable! :) I'm happy to help.

[cloudstarwolf]

Is this a fair trade for the DogTag? Please and thank you kindly!

I think it's safe to assume the pup is a nonswirl yeah? Well anyway it looks unfair to the dogtag in my opinion. The least I've ever heard of them going for is two nons and that doesn't add up to two nons unless I missed something big.

ah yeah! the pup is a non-swirl... sorry about that!

... what would have to be added? to make up the difference? How far off am I?

[Kyar]

Is this a fair trade for the DogTag? Please and thank you kindly!

I think it's safe to assume the pup is a nonswirl yeah? :) Well anyway it looks unfair to the dogtag in my opinion. The least I've ever heard of them going for is two nons and that doesn't add up to two nons unless I missed something big. :)

ah yeah! the pup is a non-swirl... sorry about that!

... what would have to be added? to make up the difference? How far off am I?

Uh... I'm not completely sure but I can tell you that what you've got there is about the non, the red tox, and a balloon dog's worth of pets. I won't give you an exact answer because I'm not sure the exact value of the dogtag. I know it's worth more than two nons though. The way it looks you've got at least a couple sorbets to go. :) Again I'm really not able to give you a certain answer so you'll probably want more opinions. :)

[Fjäll Räven]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AOd9sBRAmg
New borns are a Joker and a July PPS

[jadeillusion]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23496468&userid=396582&signature=EwaXLHlALftSYJ2RaMLaiQ

Is this fair?

Unfair to them.

Thanks c: How can I make it fair?

I think just the 11 uncommon BW on their side would be plenty since the wig is only worth 5 C$ but you could choose a few different combos with the pets on their side. You'll have to decide what you think would be fair for 5 C$ if you choose some of the more recent pets.

Thanks soo much Kyar c:

[Kyar]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AOd9sBRAmg
New borns are a Joker and a July PPS

While I can't be sure about the new URs it seems unfair to them. As far as I'm aware the moonswirl is worth three nons and the July PPS alone is worth at least two.
The sorbet, galaxy pup, and toxic would equal the third non. I tend to place jokers around a non as well due to their demand. While the new UR cat seems to be far less valuable than the dog it is still around the mid/low main list from what I've seen and I would hesitantly put the new UR dog around the big gap level.

[Solidagold]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... kjg-0h2y_g

Is this fair? c:

[Doodles]

Is this fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... AOd9sBRAmg
New borns are a Joker and a July PPS

Not neccarily. the newborn (first one) could be a card dog, and the other july litter could be a growing white july, OR a july pps. Thought i think its safe to say thats unfair to them. i believe, please do get a second opinion thought ^^;

[Doodles]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=23468684&userid=375990&signature=j2zUGEWtCehDkjg-0h2y_g

Is this fair? c:

unfair to them thier pup is an 08' VR while warrior cats have fairly good demand, its primarily unfair to them. :L